Andrew Johns and Cameron Smith SLAM bunker for allowing Penrith’s controversial try to stand 

‘It can’t be a try:’ Andrew Johns and Cameron Smith SLAM bunker for allowing Penrith’s controversial try to stand

  • Penrith beat Parramatta 28-12 in NRL Grand Final at Accor Stadium
  • Brian To’o scored two tries as Penrith won back-to-back premiership  
  • To’o second try looked to have been helped by an infringement in the build-up
  • Viliame Kikau appeared to obstruct Mitchell Moses but the try was given

The Bunker was again in the spotlight for all the wrong reasons as Penrith thrashed Parramatta 28-12 in the NRL Grand Final.

Up 18-0 following a dominant first half, Penrith crossed earlier in the second half as Brian To’o completed his double in controversial circumstances.

As Penrith swiftly moved the ball from right to left, Viliame Kikau’s decoy run ended with him slamming into Mitchell Moses.

Parramatta captain Clint Gutherson pleads his case with referee Ashley Klein (right)

The Parramatta halfback complained to referee Ashley Klein he was being impeded by Kikau, but the Bunker upheld the on-field decision and confirmed the try after reviewing the incident. 

Much to the surprise of Channel Nine’s commentary team, the video referee ruled that Moses made a ‘defensive decision’ to tackle Kikau.

‘All year that has been a no-try,’ NRL legend Andrew Johns said.

Brian To'o scored his second try of the night as Penrith extended his lead to 28-0

Brian To’o scored his second try of the night as Penrith extended his lead to 28-0

The Panthers winger delivered a dominant display as Penrith thrashed Parramatta

The Panthers winger delivered a dominant display as Penrith thrashed Parramatta

‘He had to run between Mitchell Moses and Isaiah Papali’i. He doesn’t. And Kikau runs to the outside of Moses and all year that has been a no try. 

‘The biggest game of the year, we make it [the rule] up and change it.’

Cameron Smith agreed: ‘That one is black and white. Mitchell Moses, although he might have played it slightly he does look to get to his outside. Kikau makes contact with his outside shoulder.

‘I don’t know. I’m confused now. All year Joey.’

Johns added: ‘Where he runs, Kikau, he doesn’t give Mitchell Moses the opportunity to go on the inside and slide,’ he said.

‘This has been ruled against teams all year, it can’t be a try.’ 

***
Read more at DailyMail.co.uk