News, Culture & Society

GPs slam health chiefs over ‘tone deaf’ orders to see patients face-to-face

GPs have attacked health chiefs over ‘tone deaf’ orders to make sure all patients can still get face-to-face appointments.

The British Medical Association’s GP committee has passed a vote of no confidence in NHS bosses, saying medics had been let down by the move to allow in person appointments as a matter of choice. 

Officials last week announced plans to fully embed a total triage system in which patients have to talk to a doctor on the phone or via video call before being allowed a face-to-face appointment.

But health chiefs U-turned on the move — which was brought in as a safety feature at the start of the pandemic — after critics hit out.

NHS chiefs updated guidance to say all patients have the right to see their GP face-to-face first.

But the moved sparked immediate backlash from BMA GPs, who said it was based on media backlash and not the ‘needs of the profession’.  

Dr Richard Vautrey, the BMA GP committee England chairman, said the letter ‘the final straw for many hard-working GPs’.

GPs have slammed health chiefs over ‘tone deaf’ orders to see patients face-to-face with their top medical union passing a vote of no confidence in NHS bosses

More than 90million fewer face-to-face GP appointments were carried out last year, MailOnline revealed last week

More than 90million fewer face-to-face GP appointments were carried out last year, MailOnline revealed last week

He said: ‘We know that some patients are frustrated at long waits for treatment or being unable to get a face-to-face appointment when they’d prefer one.

‘GPs everywhere share that frustration. This is not the fault of individual practices or doctors.

What was the previous guidance for GPs on about total triage? 

Patients should be remotely screened before being directed to the most appropriate health service for their problem, previous NHS guidance said.

Doctors were told the system of ‘total triage’ must be embedded into general practice, despite the Royal College of GPs’ reservations.

The method was brought in during the pandemic and sees a person checked by phone, video or online, unless clinically appropriate.

It came despite the RCGP saying patients must be able to access both remote and face-to-face doctor appointments in a post-Covid world.

In a report, general practice leaders said while remote consultations should be an option, they must not become the ‘automatic default’ for GP care.

Currently around half of consultations in general practice are being delivered face to face.

Before the pandemic, some 70 per cent of appointments were face-to-face and 30 per cent were phone, video or online; but this switched to around 30 per cent face-to-face and 70 per cent remote during the crisis.

The RCGP study pointed to benefits of online and phone care, including offering patients convenience and flexibility, which may suit people who struggle to take time off work or housebound patients.

But it said remote consultations are better suited to more straightforward conditions or queries and where a physical examination is not required.

More complex conditions or those of a sensitive nature are better suited to face-to-face appointments, it said.

It added: ‘In some cases, non-verbal or ‘soft’ cues such as signs of anxiety, self-harm, or smelling alcohol on a patient’s breath, may be more easily missed remotely, or there may be concerns about a patient’s safeguarding, capacity or confidentiality.’

The report added: ‘Every patient is likely to sit somewhere along a spectrum between needing remote and face-to-face care, and this will change according to their needs at any particular time and as symptoms or circumstances change.’

The report warned that the long-term impact of greater use of remote care on the general practice workforce is currently unknown, with some GPs reporting ‘that remote consultations can often be exhausting, leading to ‘Zoom fatigue’.’

Some 63 per cent of GPs in a poll said delivering all or mostly remote consultations reduced their job satisfaction and 61 per cent said remote consultations are making the role more transactional.

Some 88 per cent of GPs in the snap poll of 600 GPs also thought face-to-face consultations were important for building and maintaining trusting patient relationships.

The study said the extent to which patients really have a preference for remote care as the need for social distancing is lifted, is also unknown.

The College is calling on the Government to conduct a comprehensive review of total triage platforms and recognise it should not just become the default.

‘Instead of issuing tone deaf letters, in what seems to be a reaction to media coverage, rather than based on the needs of the profession, NHS England and the Government must shoulder the responsibility and face the reality of years of failing to value, support and invest in general practice to ensure that GPs and their teams have the capacity to meet the growing needs of the population.

‘This motion sounds a much-needed warning bell, rung by GPs at the end of their tether, emotionally and physically exhausted by the past 14 months. 

‘The onus is now on NHS England and ministers to fix a broken system so that patients as well as doctors have a GP service that is fit for purpose in every way.’ 

The BMA GP committee represents all GPs in the UK, regardless of BMA membership. 

Pressure group GP Survival have also called for the resignation of NHS England medical director for primary care Dr Nikki Kanani.

The group described the letter, sent las week, signed by Dr Kanani as ‘insulting’ to doctors.

In the letter, health officials had said: ‘GP practices must all ensure they are offering face-to-face appointments.

‘While the expanded use of video, online and telephone consultations can be maintained where patients find benefit from them, this should be done alongside a clear offer of appointments in person.

‘Practices should respect preferences for face-to-face care unless there are good clinical reasons to the contrary, for example the presence of Covid symptoms.’

Despite the NHS saying its preference was for face-to-face care, GPs were told last week they would be going down the opposite route.

Matt Hancock and health chiefs are keen to digitalise the NHS, with the Health Secretary last year embracing ‘Zoom medicine’ when he confirmed all consultations should be taken by phone or video call unless doctors decide they have to see a patient in person.  

But other GPs hit out at the plans, with the Royal College of GPs (RCGP) calling for the idea of more remote consultations to be overhauled.

RCGP chair Professor Martin Marshall told MailOnline that while GPs switching to more remote appointments in the early days of the pandemic was necessary for safety, he did not want to see the trend continue after the crisis is over. 

Professor Marshall said: ‘Post-pandemic, the RCGP does not want to see general practice become a totally or even mostly remote service. 

‘Face to face consulting is an essential part of general practice, and when is it safe, it needs to be down to GP practices to be able to decide, in partnership with their patients, how they deliver services. 

‘Ideally, we want patients to have the choice as to how they want to access GP services based on their health needs and preferences.’

It comes after MailOnline last week revealed there were more than 90million fewer face-to-face appointments carried out last year. 

NHS Digital statistics showed 147.85m in-person consultations happened between April 2020 and this March. This was down from the 238.26m during the same 12-month spell the year before.

Critics slammed the damning numbers, with Rachel Power, chief executive of the Patients Association, Ms Power saying: ‘Access to general practice is clearly extremely difficult for patients at the moment. 

‘The solution lies in ensuring patients get the care they need: it is not acceptable for the NHS to divert patients down routes that don’t work well simply to relieve pressure on the system – that’s not a solution. 

‘Remote appointments, which in truth are mostly by phone rather than new online systems, should remain as an option for those who want them.

She added: ‘But face-to-face appointments with GPs must be restored as the default option.’

Read more at DailyMail.co.uk