The life of Andrew Cunanan was shrouded in mystery, with few people truly knowing the man who murdered Gianni Versace.
In the premiere episode of American Crime Story, viewers were exposed to some of the many lies he told friends and strangers, along with a few shocking truths.
And none is more shocking than the fact that Versace and Cunanan had met at a San Francisco gay club in 1990, and by all accounts had a cordial conversation.
Seven years later, the friendly young man Versace met in The Golden Gate City would shoot him dead on the steps of his Miami mansion.
Operatic: The night Gianni Versace and Andrew Cunanan met is seen in the premiere episode of American Crime Story: The Assassination of Gianni Versace (Edgar ramirez and Versace and Darren Criss as Cunanan above)

Recreation: The pair met in 1990 at the San Fransisco gay club Colossus according to two eyewitnesses, who spoke with Maureen Orth for her book Vulgar Favors (Ramirez as Versace above)

Deadly friend: Versace, who was in town designing costumes for openingf night of the opera, made his way over to Cunanan, and said: ‘I know you. Lago di Como, no?’ (Criss above as Cunanan)
The depiction of how Cunanan (played by Darren Criss) came to meet Versace (played by Edar Ramirez) in American Crime Story is fairly close to how it was presented in the source material for the series, Maureen Orth’s book Vulgar Favors.
Orth spoke to two people who saw Cunanan with Versace at Colossus, a popular San Francisco gay club.
Versace reportedly stopped by the club for three straight weeks on Saturday nights while he was in the city designing costumes for the opening night of Capriccio at the San Francisco Opera.
And one at least one of those nights, and possibly two, he was seen chatting with Versace.
The first source Orth spoke to about this was Eli Gould, a friend of Cunanan’s and high-profile lawyer who said he was with Cunanan the night he met Versace.
The two men were in the VIP section at Colossus when Versace walked in with his entourage.
He later made his way over to Cunanan, and said: ‘I know you. Lago di Como, no?’

Slain: Cunanan would shoot Versace dead on the steps of the designer’s Miami mansion seven years later after a cross-country killing spree

Final look: Versace was just 55 at the time of his death, and days away from taking his compnay public
Orth writes that this was how he would strike up conversations with strangers, and that Cunanan made no attempt to correct the famed designer.
‘Thank you for remembering, Signor Versace,’ said Cunanan, and he made small talk with the designer before Gould said the two went down to the dance floor.
Eric Gruenwald, another attorney, claims he too saw Versace and Cunanan speaking at the club one night, though it is unclear if that was the same night he was with Gould or another evening.
The rest however, was all a lie, with Cunanan’s claims that he accompanied Versace to opening night of the opera and claims that the two had dinner together once a year nothing more than a fantasy.
That fantasy eventually turned fatal, and the aftermath of Versace’s murder can be seen next Tuesday on American Crime Story: The Assassination of Gianni Versace.