Boris Johnson suffered the first major setback of his infant premiership today as his Commons’ majority was reduced to just one after the Tories were humiliated in the Brecon and Radnorshire by-election.
The Liberal Democrats’ Jane Dodds gave the Prime Minister a political headache as she overcame an 8,000-vote Conservative majority to take the Welsh seat for the Remainer party.
Disgraced expenses cheat Tory Chris Davies, whose conviction and expulsion via a recall petition forced the summer vote, held on to second under a concerted attack by the Brexit Party’s Des Parkinson.
The vote shows the job Mr Johnson still has to do with 90 days to go until Britain is due to leave the EU.
Ms Dodds, 55, who won with a majority of 1,425, said the result was ‘sending a message to Westminster that we demand better’.
And she said her first job in London would be to find the Prime Minister and tell him to ‘stop playing with the future of our communities and rule out a No Deal Brexit now.’
And there was more bad news for Jeremy Corbyn as Labour’s Tom Davies was beaten into fourth place by the Brexit Party’s Des Parkinson and narrowly avoided losing his deposit.
The Lib Dems’ Jane Dodds was all smiles as she arrived at the count this morning with MP Ed Davey
Disgraced expenses cheat Tory Chris Davies, whose conviction and expulsion via a recall petition forced the summer vote, held on to second
Labour’s Tom Davies was beaten into fourth place by the Brexit Party’s Des Parkinson and narrowly avoided losing his deposit.
The vote in the Welsh borders constituency yesterday was sparked by the criminal conviction of Tory MP Chris Davies for expenses fraud in March and a subsequent recall petition.
But the Tories’ decision to allow the disgraced ex-MP to contest the seat despite local people voting to oust him means that the Liberal Democrats are the favourites to overturn the Conservatives’ 8,000 majority from 2017.
The other Remainer parties stood aside to give their candidate Jane Dodds a clear run to take a seat the party won as recently as 2010.
Defeat for the Tories in Brecon and Radnorshire would see the Prime Minister’s majority in the rebellious and fragmented Commons fall to just one – including the DUP – and add a Remainer to the force opposing him.
The Prime Minister faces an anxious wait as counting gets underway in Brecon and Radnorshire (including the Royal Welsh Showground, above) to see if the ‘Boris Bounce’ can lead to an unlikely win for the Tories
In a move that has caused despair among ministers, the local Tory party chose Chris Davies (pictured voting yesterday with wife Liz) to stand in Brecon & Radnorshire again despite his conviction for expenses fraud
Boris Johnson (pictured at Downing Street) faces crashing down to earth today in his first real electoral test – which could reduce his Commons majority to just one
Turnout in the election in the UK’s largest constituency was 59.7 per cent, the highest in a by-election since 1997.
A Welsh Liberal Democrat source said they expected the result to be ‘a lot closer than we thought’ but was still confident of beating the Conservatives.
The source said: ‘We are confident we can do this, but it isn’t in the bag. It’s a big majority we’re looking to overturn across a big seat. Our campaign has put us in a good place.’
A Welsh Conservative Party source said they believed Boris Johnson’s appointment as Prime Minister had boosted Brexiteer support for the party, saying the number of votes between them and the Lib Dems would be ‘closer than people thought’.
Mr Johnson has dramatically boosted the party’s national ratings, with one poll yesterday suggesting it was 10 points ahead of Labour.
A close eye will also be kept on the performance of the Brexit Party, which is hoping to secure second place ahead of the Tories.
Mr Johnson’s solemn ‘do or die’ vow to take the UK out of the EU by the end of October appears to have reversed some of the haemorrhage of support to Nigel Farage’s fledgling outfit.
If the combined vote of the Tories and Brexit Party is more than that for the Lib Dems, the outcome could also heap pressure on the PM to consider a pact in a potential election widely expected within the next year.
Mr Davies, 51, was picked by local members despite his conviction and a subsequent recall petition signed by 20 per cent of voters demanding he be ejected from the seat.
Mr Johnson made a fleeting visit to Brecon earlier this week, attending the offices of the BVG Group with Mr Davies.
Commons Leader Jacob Rees-Mogg and Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster Michael Gove have both visited the constituency in recent weeks.
The Brexit Party fears that the ‘Boris Bounce’ from the new Prime Minister’s appointment last week could see them forced into third
Six parties are contesting the by-election after Remainer parties pulled out to allow the Lib Dems a free run to try and take the seat
The result of the by-election is expected to be annnounced at around 3am
The Liberal Democrats are trying to not look complacent, talking about the size of the rural seat making its doorstep efforts harder.
A source said: ‘It’s certainly not in the bag, we are in a good place but we know we need to keep knocking on doors.’
The Brexit Party is hoping to steal votes from disaffected Tories with its candidate, former local police superintendent Des Parkinson, 71.
But a party spokesman conceded that the ‘Boris Bounce’ from the new Prime Minister’s appointment last week could see them run close.
However he also pointed to Mr Johnson’s comments in Wales on Tuesday that Britain could remain in the customs union and single market for another two years after Brexit, suggesting a negotiated deal with Brussels was still possible.
The spokesman said: ‘They put up a guy who is busted, which is extraordinary.
A close eye will also be kept on the performance of the Brexit Party (whose bus was in Llandrindod Wells yesterday, above), which is hoping to secure second place ahead of the Tories and could split the Brexit vote
The polls opened in the Brecon & Radnorshire by-election yesterday (pictured) with the Tories hoping the boost from a new PM can save them
Voters in the Brecon & Radnorshire constituency were up and about early as they decide who their next MP will be
A YouGov poll for the Times yesterday found the Tories had gained seven percentage points in support over the past week – and were 10 points ahead of Labour
‘They will try to point the finger at us but they only have themselves to blame, putting up someone who is busted like that.
‘Secondly they must realise from results like this that unless they deliver on the promises made (on Brexit) they will not be the governing party.’
A swing of 9.8 per cent would be needed by Lib Dem candidate Jane Dodds to win the seat, which saw a majority of 8,038 for Mr Davies in 2017.
It is the sort of swing which, were it to happen at a general election, could see the party pick up around a dozen seats from the Tories.
However, a poll of the area by the Number Crunching Politics website last week suggested that the Remainer party is on course to achieve a 14 per cent swing from the Tories to 43 per cent.
It puts the Tories in second on 28 per cent, ahead of the Brexit Party on 20 per cent, with Labour and the Monster Raving Loony Party coming in ahead of Ukip.
But on Monday a separate poll suggested the ‘Boris bounce’ had spread to Wales, finding the Tories had leapfrogged Labour.
A survey found the Conservatives had jumped seven points since May on voting intention for a general election.
Chris Davies secured a majority of more than 8,000 for the Tories at the 2017 general election
They now enjoy a slender two-point advantage over Jeremy Corbyn’s party – which was down three on 22 per cent, the lowest level ever recorded.
However, the YouGov research for Cardiff University and ITV underlines the fragmentation in party support in Wales.
Despite being down five points since the last poll just before the European elections, the Brexit Party was on 18 per cent, while the Lib Dems were up four on 16 per cent. Plaid Cymru is also riding high on 15 per cent.
Defeat for the Conservatives in the by-election in Brecon and Radnorshire would see the Government’s working majority in Parliament shrink to just one.
There are currently 320 MPs who – on paper – would back the Government in a crunch vote in the House of Commons – 310 Tories and 10 members of the DUP.
The DUP agreed to support the Conservatives in certain key votes, such as confidence motions and Budgets, as part of a deal reached in the aftermath of the 2017 general election.
The Lib Dems’ Jane Dodds (left) is the odds-on favourite to win the by-election, with the Brexit Party’s Des Parkinson (right) hoping to sneak second
Mr Johnson made a fleeting visit to Brecon on Tuesday evening with candidate Chris Davies, who was convicted of expenses fraud earlier this year
Set against this combined total of 320 MPs are 318 MPs from all other parties.
The seat of Brecon and Radnorshire is currently vacant, so whoever wins the by-election will increase by one either the Government’s tally of MPs or those of the opposition.
The Liberal Democrats are favourites to win the seat, and, were they to do so, the opposition tally would increase from 318 to 319.
With the Tories and DUP unchanged on a combined total of 320, this would reduce the Government’s majority from two to one.
These totals do not include Sinn Fein’s seven MPs, who do not take their seats in the Commons, and the Speaker and three Deputy Speakers, who do not vote.
The Lib Dems held the seat of Brecon and Radnorshire from 1997 to 2015, since when it has been held by the Tories.
The party won 49 per cent of the vote in 2017, compared with 29 per cent for the Lib Dems, 18 per cent for Labour, 3 per cent for Plaid Cymru and 1 per cent for Ukip.
In this week’s by-election, Plaid Cymru is not standing and has instead urged its supporters to vote for the Lib Dems. The Green Party has done the same.
Both parties have stated that they want to try to maximise the chance of success for the Lib Dems.
The result of the by-election is expected to be declared at around 3am on Friday morning.
Who are the candidates in the Brecon By-election?
Brexit Party: Des Parkinson. The retired Dyfed-Powys Police chief superintendent, 71, who wants to cut local council tax and opposes wind farms being built in the attractive rural area. A former Ukipper he ran unsuccessfully to be the area’s Police and Crime Commissioner in 2016. He attacked Boris Johnson today, writing in Politics Home that ‘if he really wanted a clean Brexit he would have asked the tainted Tory to stand down’.
Welsh Conservatives: Chris Davies – The 51-year-old former MP for the seat. In April this year the ex-auctioneer, who is married with two young children, was given a community order after admitting two charges of expenses fraud over false invoices for photographs, sparking a recall petition and this by-election. A Brexiteer who has been backed by the party despite his conviction, including a brief visit by the Prime Minister yesterday.
Welsh Labour: Tom Davies. The Brecon born and raised lawyer, 29, sits on the town’s council. He trained as a barrister and works in Cwmbran, while living in Brecon. He’s a fluent Welsh-speaker and rugby fan. He supports a second referendum but is not expected to win. Labour is projected to finish fourth behind the Lib Dems, Tories and the Brexit Party tomorrow.
Welsh Lib Dems: Jane Dodds. The 55-year-old married child protection social worker and Welsh Lib Dem leader is the favourite to take the seat which was held by the party as recently as 2010. She is also a Welsh-speaker and was born and raised in Wrexham in the north of the country. She won the candidacy after a vote of party members and contested Montgomeryshire in 2015 and 2017.
Ukip: Liz Phillips. The former personal assistant to former Ukip leader Gerard Batten lived for a long time in Rhayader in the constituency but currently lives in Kent. She faces a struggle to win votes from the Brexit Party. She previously contested the seat at the 2001 and 2005 elections – on the latter occasion finishing last.
Monster Raving Loony: Lady Lily The Pink. Representing the perennial election also-rans, Lily, who lives in Brecon, is targeting people not planning to vote because they don’t like the more mainstream candidates, using the slogan ‘if you don’t know what to think, vote Pink’.