News, Culture & Society

St Kilda denied goal in controversial ruling as magnificent Melbourne hammer them in the first half

Red-hot reigning premiers Melbourne have made another emphatic statement by crushing finals contenders St Kilda en route to their 15th straight AFL win.

A defensive masterclass set up Sunday’s 38-point victory at the MCG to give the Saints a giant reality check as they slumped to back-to-back defeats.

Melbourne kicked the first five goals of the match and led by as much as 47 points late in the second quarter before running out winners 14.9 (93) to 8.7 (55).

Demons veteran Angus Brayshaw celebrates after kicking a stunner from about 50 metres out on a tight angle as Melbourne gave the Saints a football lesson early on

The Demons coasted to victories in the first seven rounds mostly against teams not expected to finish inside the top eight but came out firing with their premiership-best against the Saints, who started the round in fourth place with a 5-2 record.

Melbourne stamped their authority early by strangling the Saints’ ball movement and capitalising on each of their own forward forays.

Kysaiah Pickett starred early for Melbourne, Ben Brown had three goals by three-quarter time and Clayton Oliver led all players with 28 possessions.  

Oliver and Angus Brayshaw were in typically prolific moods in the midfield, while Steven May, Jake Lever and Harrison Petty completely controlled the air down back.

St Kilda were always likely to need all the help they could get to beat the red-hot Demons on Sunday – but they ended up copping a controversial call that denied them a desperately needed goal instead.

With Melbourne leading 4.2 (26) to 0.2 (2) in the first quarter, Saints centre half forward Tim Membrey marked slightly to the left of goal about 15 metres out and kicked true – only for the goal ump to call it touched.

A score review followed and was inconclusive, leading to an umpire’s call – and the behind stood.

Tim Membrey was blamed for making a 'rookie error' that resulted in Harrison Petty getting a fingertip to the ball and denying St Kilda a crucial goal

Tim Membrey was blamed for making a ‘rookie error’ that resulted in Harrison Petty getting a fingertip to the ball and denying St Kilda a crucial goal

Saints fans howled in protest at the ground and online, but former Collingwood coach Nathan Buckley laid the blame squarely at Membrey’s feet.

‘Rookie error comes to mind. Tim Membrey isn’t a rookie, but sometimes when you’re under pressure the simple things aren’t done well,’ Buckley said.

‘He just didn’t give himself enough space.’

However, fans were quick to launch into the man on the mark, Harrison Petty, and claim he was at fault for breaking the stand rule.

But many Saints fans blew up at the umpire who called it (pictured) and said the Demons defender had broken the stand rule by jumping off the mark

But many Saints fans blew up at the umpire who called it (pictured) and said the Demons defender had broken the stand rule by jumping off the mark

‘Standing on the mark rule just disappeared, didn’t know you could jump forward,’ wrote Nick Lambden-Grant.

‘What about the stand rule?’ asked Michael White.

‘Fifty metre penalty,’ tweeted Leon Tracy.

The first half got far worse from there for St Kilda, with the Demons piling on four unanswered goals early in the second term, leading 52-9 at one point before the Saints pulled them back to make it 9.3 (57) to 3.4 (22) at the main break.  

The Saints saved themselves from embarrassment by performing better in the second-half as Melbourne lost a third-quarter for the first time this season.

Zak Jones impressed in his first game for the 2022 season, but could find himself on the sideline again after a controversial hit on Melbourne's Ed Langdon

Zak Jones impressed in his first game for the 2022 season, but could find himself on the sideline again after a controversial hit on Melbourne’s Ed Langdon

Coach Brett Ratten might want to record his halftime talk and use it again this year as his charges restricted the Dees to one goal in the third quarter while kicking two themselves to reduce the gap to 28 points going into the last period. 

Saints midfielder Zak Jones made an encouraging first appearance for the season after returning from personal leave but could find himself in trouble with the match review officer for a hit on Demons flyer Ed Langdon in the last quarter. 

Tom McDonald (right) chest bumps Tom Sparrow after kicking a sausage roll in the second quarter as the Dees piled on the misery

Tom McDonald (right) chest bumps Tom Sparrow after kicking a sausage roll in the second quarter as the Dees piled on the misery

In further concern for St Kilda, small forward Dan Butler was subbed out with a lower leg injury ahead of the last quarter and replaced by Marcus Windhager. 

St Kilda will be hoping to get back on the winners list when they host Geelong at Marvel Stadium on Saturday.

Things could get seriously ugly next Sunday as Melbourne face hapless West Coast, who have lost their last four games by an average of 83 points, at Optus Stadium. 

***
Read more at DailyMail.co.uk