Australian Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull has dismissed calls to change colonial-era monuments and the date of Australia Day as ‘Stalinist’ exercises in rewriting history.
It comes as debate intensified over the country’s treatment of its Aboriginal population.
Moves to remove Confederate statues and other Civil War-era symbols in the United States have renewed focus on the mistreatment of Aboriginal Australians in the colonial era and recognition of their place in the nation’s history.
Prominent indigenous commentator Stan Grant this week pointed to the ‘damaging myth’ inscribed on a Sydney statue of British explorer Captain James Cook that says he ‘Discovered this territory 1770’.
Australia’s colonial history credits Cook with discovering the country, but Aboriginal people inhabited the land for more than 60,000 years before the first European explorers arrived
Australia’s colonial history credits Cook with discovering the country, but Aboriginal people inhabited the land for more than 60,000 years before the first European explorers arrived.
Turnbull, however, said attempts to remove or alter such statues were mistaken.
‘Trying to edit our history is wrong,’ Turnbull told Melbourne radio station 3AW.
‘All of those statues, all of those monuments, are part of our history and we should respect them and preserve them.’
Australian PM Malcolm Turnbull (pictured) said: ‘We can’t get into this sort of Stalinist exercise of trying to white-out or obliterate or blank-out parts of our history’
It comes as Afua Hirsch, a journalist for Sky News, said it was time to ‘look at’ Britain’s ‘landscape’ – starting with the statue of the ‘white supremacist’ Horatio Nelson in Trafalgar Square.
In an article for the Guardian, titled ‘Toppling statues? Here’s why Nelson’s Column should be next’, she argued that the ‘colonial and pro-slavery titans of British history’ should stop being ‘memorialised’.
She wrote that Nelson was ‘what you would now call, without hesitation, a white supremacist’ and that his influence hindered the progress of the slavery abolitionists.
Sydney council this week referred concerns about the Cook statue to an indigenous advisory board.
Next for the chop? In an article for the Guardian, titled ‘Toppling statues? Here’s why Nelson’s Column should be next’, Ms Hirsch argued that the ‘colonial and pro-slavery titans of British history’ should stop being ‘memorialised’
The board will also examine memorials to New South Wales’ colonial-era governor Lachlan Macquarie, who critics say ordered massacres of indigenous people.
The uproar follows a vote by two local councils in Victoria state to no longer recognise January 26 as Australia Day.
The date commemorates the arrival of the country’s first British settlers, but is termed ‘Invasion Day’ by many indigenous Australians who say it marks the beginning of the decline of Aboriginal culture.
Turnbull said attempts to change the national day and alter monuments were being pushed by ‘fringe’ leftists.
‘I think the vast majority of Australians are as horrified as you and I are at the thought that we’re going to go around rewriting history, editing the inscriptions on statues, deleting Australia Day,’ he said.
‘If you want to write a new chapter to our history, if you want to challenge assumptions in the past, by all means do so.
‘But we can’t get into this sort of Stalinist exercise of trying to white-out or obliterate or blank-out parts of our history.’
Conservative commentators in Australia have accused critics of bowing to political correctness and stoking racial friction.
Grant, the Australian Broadcasting Corporation’s indigenous affairs editor, countered by saying that statues need not come down, but a deeper discussion about the country’s history was required.
It follows violent protests in the US over a statue of Confederate leader Robert E Lee, which many argued celebrates America’s slave-owning past
‘There is a history in Australia of not wanting to talk about the darker parts of our shared past,’ he wrote this week.
Aboriginals were believed to have numbered around one million at the time of British settlement, but now make up only about three percent of the total national population of 24 million.
They remain the most disadvantaged Australians, with higher rates of poverty, ill-health and imprisonment than any other community in the country.