Downcast Duncan James forced to go back to Cartier to exchange super expensive gift after Evelyn Ellis said he ‘stuffed up’ her birthday present

Married At First Sight’s Duncan James was less than impressed after he was forced to exchange an expensive gift he purchased his girlfriend Evelyn Ellis.

The reality TV star, 37, shared a video to Instagram of the moment he surprised his girlfriend with jewellery from Cartier on her birthday.

But he was left devastated when she opened the box and informed him she already had the same necklace.

‘Stuffing up her birthday gift last week,’ he captioned the video.

He then shared another video of himself taking Evelyn to the luxury jewellery store to exchange her gift.

In the video, a downcast Duncan is seen waiting in a long line to enter the store while holding the unwanted gift.

After making it inside, Evelyn can’t wipe the smile off her face as she tried on a silver Juste un Clou bracelet, which retails for $6250.

Duncan is then seen paying for the item before leaving the store.

MAFS’ Duncan James was less than impressed after he was forced to exchange an expensive gift he purchased his girlfriend Evelyn Ellis

Duncan shared a video to Instagram of the moment he surprised his girlfriend with jewellery from Cartier on her birthday. But he was devastated when she opened the box and informed him she already had the same necklace

Duncan shared a video to Instagram of the moment he surprised his girlfriend with jewellery from Cartier on her birthday. But he was devastated when she opened the box and informed him she already had the same necklace

‘I’ve realised it always costs more when you go back a second time,’ he captioned the hilarious video.

Duncan and Evelyn have been going strong since announcing they were dating in May last year.

Evelyn confirmed her relationship with fellow MAFS groom Duncan, who was paired with Alyssa Barmonde on the show.

The pair, who were pictured kissing and cuddling on a date night in Sydney, revealed it was ‘exhilarating’ and ‘freeing’ to finally go public after months of rumours.

‘We are in a relationship. This is our hard launch,’ Evelyn told Nine.com.au at the time.

‘It feels good to finally just say it and it feels kind of exhilarating in a weird, freeing way,’ the Maxim cover girl added with a laugh.

He then shared another video while taking Evelyn to the luxury jewellery store to exchange her gift

He then shared another video while taking Evelyn to the luxury jewellery store to exchange her gift

Married At First Sight AustraliaDuncan James

***
Read more at DailyMail.co.uk