Man who stabbed his wife in the neck after making her a cup of tea told police he ‘didn’t know why’ he did it as he is jailed for 14 years
- Alan Lloyd Greentree, now 63, pleaded guilty to murdering Dawn Butterworth
- In the lead up to the murder the couple were experiencing financial difficulties
- He made her a cup of tea before stabbing her in the neck and chest repeatedly
- Greentree repeatedly said to police he didn’t know why he stabbed his wife
A Sydney man who can give no reason at all for stabbing his long-term partner to death after making her a cup of tea has been jailed for at least 14 years.
‘There is no motive for the offending and the offender appears, genuinely, to be unable to give an explanation for the offending,’ Justice David Davies said in the NSW Supreme Court on Friday.
Alan Lloyd Greentree, now 63, pleaded guilty to murdering Dawn Butterworth, 67, at their rented unit in Penshurst in mid-August 2018.
Months earlier, Greentree lost his job as a bartender at Kareela Golf Club for allegedly providing drinks for the kitchen staff which were not paid for.
Alan Lloyd Greentree, now 63, pleaded guilty to murdering Dawn Butterworth, 67, at their rented unit in Penshurst in mid-August 2018. Pictured: The scene
Ms Butterworth, who had been his de facto wife for about 30 years, was on the aged pension, suffered serious longstanding health problems and had been referred to palliative care.
Greentree had been her primary carer.
In the lead-up to the murder, the couple experienced financial difficulties and was facing eviction which had left Ms Butterworth extremely distressed.
On the morning of August 13, Greentree woke up, had a cup of tea, watched TV, made a shopping list and when his partner came into the lounge room made her a cup of tea.
‘The offender told the police that he was about to go out shopping when he then picked up a knife from the kitchen, walked to where the deceased was sitting in the armchair and, from behind her, stabbed her once in the back right side of her neck,’ the judge said.
She tried to stand up but fell to the floor, asking: ‘What are you doing, what are you doing, what have I done?’
Greentree stabbed his de-facto partner in the neck before she tried to stand and he pushed her down and stabbed her in the chest. Scene pictured
He stabbed her again on the right side of her chest and held her down by the shoulders until she stopped moving.
Greentree then cut his right wrist, causing a superficial laceration, drank alcohol and Ms Butterworth’s liquid morphine and lay on his bed, where he was found by her home care nurse.
In his police interview, he repeatedly said he did not know why he stabbed her, denying there had been any violence within the relationship or having ever hit her.
He had no mental health history and when asked by a counsellor if he had any idea whey he killed his partner, he said: ‘No, I can’t – I can’t think why, don’t know.’
Greentree did not relate their financial stresses to the killing and denied having any relationship stresses.
‘There was no evidence to suggest that it was a mercy killing,’ the judge said.
At his sentence hearing, Greentree said the couple had been happy and the judge accepted he was extremely remorseful.
‘This is an unusual case,’ he said, noting Greentree had no criminal record and was a person of good character.
He jailed him for 18 years and nine months with a non-parole period of 14 years.