Justin Glaze unexpectedly returned to the beach on Monday night’s two-hour episode of Bachelor in Paradise on ABC with a date card for Eliza Isichei.
Moments before Justin arrived, Rodney Mathews, 30, a sales rep from Rancho Cucamonga, California, was feeling very confident about his relationship with Eliza, 26, a marketing manager from Berlin. He was already thinking about their life together after the show.
Justin, 28, an investment sales consultant, from Baltimore, Maryland, then returned to Paradise and told host Jesse Palmer, 44, that he came back just for Eliza.
He’s back: Justin Glaze unexpectedly returned to the beach on Monday night’s two-hour episode of Bachelor in Paradise on ABC with a date card for Eliza Isichei
‘Hope this one goes better,’ Jesse said.
Justin walked on to the beach with the date card for Eliza. He immediately asked Eliza to go and talk. Rodney kept a smile on his face watching them thinking Justin would also pull other women aside, too. After chatting, Justin asked Eliza if she would go on a date with him and she said yes.
Eliza went to talk to Rodney.
‘I want him to say you’re mine,’ Eliza said in a confessional.
![Said yes: Eliza despite spending time with Rodney Mathews said yes to a date with Justin](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2022/11/01/07/64058865-11375581-image-a-71_1667288311531.jpg)
Said yes: Eliza despite spending time with Rodney Mathews said yes to a date with Justin
Eliza told Rodney that Justin asked her out on a date. She asked him how he felt about it.
‘I’m here for you but I don’t want you feeling pressure thinking that you’re breaking my heart, you’re hurting me or anything like that,’ Rodney said. ‘I want you to be happy.’
‘You want me to go?’ Eliza said.
![Rose ceremony: During the earlier rose ceremony, Eliza gave her rose to Rodney](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2022/11/01/07/64058665-11375581-image-a-72_1667288360115.jpg)
Rose ceremony: During the earlier rose ceremony, Eliza gave her rose to Rodney
‘Personally, I don’t,’ Rodney said. ‘I think it’s what’s best because if you go and you get clarity, or you get confirmation, or you miss me then I’m clearly the one that you want.’
‘I kind of want you to tell me you don’t want me to go,’ Eliza said.
Eliza started to cry. She felt that Rodney didn’t like her if he was okay with her going date with someone else. Brandon Jones, 28, a traveling nurse recruiter, from Portland, couldn’t believe Eliza was going to go on a date.
![Going strong: Brandon Jones and Serene Russell remained tight as other relationships were tested](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2022/11/01/07/64058651-11375581-image-a-73_1667288402207.jpg)
Going strong: Brandon Jones and Serene Russell remained tight as other relationships were tested
Rodney told Brandon that he regretted not telling Eliza about how he felt.
‘I just want her to still come back tonight and choose me for me because she actually missed me,’ said Rodney on the beach to Brandon.
‘She likes you a lot,’ Brandon said. ‘At the end of the day, she is going to choose you.’
Rodney sat on the beach waiting for Eliza to come back. Eliza meanwhile kissed Justin at the end of their date as fireworks exploded in the air above them.
![Instant chemistry: Eliza meanwhile kissed Justin at the end of their date as fireworks exploded in the air above them](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2022/11/01/07/64058859-11375581-image-a-74_1667288436592.jpg)
Instant chemistry: Eliza meanwhile kissed Justin at the end of their date as fireworks exploded in the air above them
When the show opened, Victoria Fuller was deciding between Alex Bordyukov, 33, an information system supervisor from Grosse Point, Michigan, and Johnny DePhillipo, 26, a realtor from Palm Beach Gardens, Florida.
‘I have two amazing men that I absolutely adore,’ Victoria said in a confessional. ‘Tonight is going to be really hard for me.’
At the evening ceremony, host Jesse arrived and informed them that Sarah Hamrick, 24, a wealth management advisor from Spartanburg, South Carolina, had a family emergency and left the island. Jesse said with 11 guys and 10 women, the women would be handing out the roses.
![Early exit: At the evening ceremony, host Jesse arrived and informed them that Sarah Hamrick, 24, a wealth management advisor from Spartanburg, South Carolina, had a family emergency and left the island](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2022/11/01/07/64058647-11375581-image-a-75_1667288492509.jpg)
Early exit: At the evening ceremony, host Jesse arrived and informed them that Sarah Hamrick, 24, a wealth management advisor from Spartanburg, South Carolina, had a family emergency and left the island
‘I’m going full petal to the metal here, because I don’t play to lose,’ Alex, 33, said to the camera.
Jacob Rapini , 28, a mortgage broker from Scottsdale, Arizona, and Shanae Ankney, 30, a recruiter from Sycamore, Ohio, bonded over their passion for keeping their teeth clean. Jacob and Shanae each took turns brushing each other’s teeth with charcoal toothpaste.
![Clean teeth: Jacob Rapini , 28, a mortgage broker from Scottsdale, Arizona, and Shanae Ankney, 30, a recruiter from Sycamore, Ohio, bonded over their passion for keeping their teeth clean](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2022/11/01/07/64059015-11375581-image-a-76_1667288730076.jpg)
Clean teeth: Jacob Rapini , 28, a mortgage broker from Scottsdale, Arizona, and Shanae Ankney, 30, a recruiter from Sycamore, Ohio, bonded over their passion for keeping their teeth clean
‘This is the best date,’ Shanae said.
The two kissed.
Alex chatted with Victoria. Johnny was not happy to see them walking together on the beach.
![New couple: Logan and Shanae kissed](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2022/11/01/07/64058635-11375581-image-m-78_1667288776869.jpg)
New couple: Logan and Shanae kissed
‘If I were to lose her, I would definitely be heartbroken,’ Johnny said in a confessional.
Johnny told Aaron Clancy, 28, an insurance agent from San Diego, he was developing feelings for Victoria and hoped that she would realize that what they had was real. He said he would leave if Victoria picked Alex.
Victoria went to talk to Johnny and asked him about his week. He said his week was hell.
![Rough week: Victoria went to talk to Johnny and asked him about his week](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2022/11/01/07/64058657-11375581-image-a-79_1667288818282.jpg)
Rough week: Victoria went to talk to Johnny and asked him about his week
‘Watching you with someone else was just the hardest thing,’ Johnny said. ‘I like you a lot.’
‘I like you a lot,’ Victoria said.
‘I know what I want, I want Victoria,’ Johnny said in a confessional. ‘It’s so tough right now.’
![Tough time: 'I know what I want, I want Victoria,' Johnny said in a confessional. 'It's so tough right now'](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2022/11/01/07/64059051-11375581-image-a-80_1667288865011.jpg)
Tough time: ‘I know what I want, I want Victoria,’ Johnny said in a confessional. ‘It’s so tough right now’
‘I’m so attracted to both,’ Victoria said. ‘I don’t know what to do.’
There were a few surprises at the evening’s rose ceremony. Serene Russell, 26, an elementary school teacher from Oklahoma City, gave her rose to Brandon. Danielle Maltby gave hers to Michael Allio, 38, a single father from Akron, Ohio. Eliza gave hers to Rodney. Genevieve Parisi gave hers to Aaron.
Jessenia Cruz , 30, a social media marketer from San Antonio, Texas, gave hers to Andrew Spencer, 27, a pro-football player from Vienna, Austria. Brittany Galvin, 25, a model from Chicago gave hers to Tyler Norris, 26, a small business owner from Wildwood, New Jersey. Kate Gallivan, 33, a real estate agent from Los Angeles gave her rose to Logan Palmer, 26, a production technician from San Diego. Shanae gave her rose to Jacob.
![Rose accepted: Tyler Norris accepted a rose offered by Brittany Galvin](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2022/11/01/07/64058685-11375581-image-a-81_1667288993875.jpg)
Rose accepted: Tyler Norris accepted a rose offered by Brittany Galvin
At the end of the ceremony, Victoria ultimately picked Johnny over Alex.
‘I feel like a king right now,’ Johnny said in a confessional. ‘Right now Alex is on the chopping block. It would be great if he would pack up and leave tonight.’
But then Florence Alexandra , 31, from Australia swooped in and gave Alex her rose.
![Tough choice: At the end of the ceremony, Victoria ultimately picked Johnny over Alex](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2022/11/01/07/64058683-11375581-image-a-82_1667289036295.jpg)
Tough choice: At the end of the ceremony, Victoria ultimately picked Johnny over Alex
Johnny was not happy.
‘I don’t want him watching over me,’ Johnny said. ‘He said his piece, he shot his shot. Just go away.’
Adam Todd, 25, from The Bachelorette Australia did not get a rose and was sent home.
The next day on the beach, the couples did feel more secure. Johnny told Logan that he wished Alex had been kicked out of Paradise.
A date card arrived on the beach and it was for Victoria. Victoria asked Johnny to go on the date with her.
![Date card: Victoria asked Johnny to go on the date with her](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2022/11/01/07/64059009-11375581-image-a-83_1667289074126.jpg)
Date card: Victoria asked Johnny to go on the date with her
‘I’m on top of the world,’ Johnny said to the camera.
Johnny and Victoria hugged in front of Alex and then left on their date.
‘If I was a gambling man, I would say they are not a good match,’ Alex said. ‘So I will be patiently waiting for her to come back.’
![Safe bet: 'If I was a gambling man, I would say they are not a good match,' Alex said. 'So I will be patiently waiting for her to come back'](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2022/11/01/07/64059205-11375581-image-a-84_1667289206611.jpg)
Safe bet: ‘If I was a gambling man, I would say they are not a good match,’ Alex said. ‘So I will be patiently waiting for her to come back’
The two met with a shaman who had them go inside a sweat lodge and encouraged to share their fears.
Victoria told Johnny she feared being hurt at the end of this.
‘I’m just scared because I really like you,’ Victoria.
‘I feel like I’m not good enough for you,’ Johnny said.
![Feeling scared: 'I'm just scared because I really like you,' Victoria told Johnny](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2022/11/01/07/64059053-11375581-image-a-85_1667289221775.jpg)
Feeling scared: ‘I’m just scared because I really like you,’ Victoria told Johnny
Johnny told her that he didn’t want to let her go and that he felt that he was falling in love with her.
‘I can see a future with you,’ Victoria said. ‘I feel like I’m falling in love with you’
Seeing Justin back also did not make Genevieve happy. Aaron got nervous because Genevieve had a connection with Justin and now talked about him a lot.
![Interesting development: Aaron got nervous because Genevieve had a connection with Justin and started talking about him a lot after he came back](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2022/11/01/07/64059033-11375581-image-a-86_1667289246186.jpg)
Interesting development: Aaron got nervous because Genevieve had a connection with Justin and started talking about him a lot after he came back
‘It makes me feel like I was option two,’ Aaron said in a confessional.
Genevieve talked about Justin in front of Aaron then stormed off. She went off looking for him. Aaron told her she made it seem that it wasn’t his success that brought them together but Justin’s failing.
‘I wanted it to be that you like me not because Justin was a d***,’ Aaron said.
![Show bartender: Wells Adams was behind the bar when Aaron suddenly left](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2022/11/01/07/64059025-11375581-image-a-87_1667289280599.jpg)
Show bartender: Wells Adams was behind the bar when Aaron suddenly left
Genevieve started crying. She told him she was upset because she likes him so much. Genevieve apologized to Aaron for making him upset.
‘It’s you I chose,’ Genevieve said.
Genevieve hugged Aaron as he cried.
‘I just wanted someone to understand me,’ Aaron said.
‘It would actually crush me to lose him,’ Genevieve said in a confessional. ‘I am falling in love with Aaron.’
Bachelor in Paradise will return Tuesday night on ABC.
![Falling hard: 'It would actually crush me to lose him,' Genevieve said in a confessional. 'I am falling in love with Aaron'](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2022/11/01/07/64059045-11375581-image-a-88_1667289317148.jpg)
Falling hard: ‘It would actually crush me to lose him,’ Genevieve said in a confessional. ‘I am falling in love with Aaron’
***
Read more at DailyMail.co.uk