At least two tons of highly unstable chemicals used in the production of plastics and paint blew up and burned at a flooded plant near Houston, sending up a plume of acrid black smoke that stung the eyes and lungs, raising health concerns.
The fire that began early Thursday at the Arkema Inc chemical plant in suburban Crosby, about 25 miles northeast of Houston, burned out around midday, but emergency crews continued to hold back because of the danger that eight other trailers containing the same highly unstable chemical compound could blow, too.
No serious injuries were reported. But the blast added a new hazard to Harvey’s aftermath and raised questions about the adequacy of the company’s master plan to protect the public in the event of an emergency in the flood-prone Houston metropolitan area of 5.6 million people.
Stricken plant: At least 2 tons of highly unstable chemicals at the Arkema Inc chemical plant in Crosby, Texas, blew up Thursday amid flooding
The photo of the left shows the Arkema plant in Crosby on January 29. The image on the right shows the same plant on August 31, after Harvey
A fire burns at the flooded plant of French chemical maker Arkema SA after Tropical Storm Harvey passed in Crosby oin Thursday
Organic peroxides stored at the plant blew up because Harvey’s floodwaters engulfed the backup generators and knocked out refrigeration
The Environmental Protection Agency and Texas environmental regulators called the health risks minimal in Crosby, but urged residents downwind from the flood-stricken plant to stay indoors with windows closed to avoid inhaling the noxious smoke drifting from the blast site.
Arkema had warned earlier in the week that an explosion of organic peroxides stored at the plant was imminent because Harvey’s floodwaters engulfed the backup generators and knocked out the refrigeration necessary to keep the compounds from degrading and catching fire.
All employees had been pulled from the plant before the explosion, and up to 5,000 people living within one-and-a-half miles had been warned to evacuate on Tuesday.
Two explosions in the middle of the night blew open a trailer containing the chemicals, lighting up the sky with 30- to 40-foot flames in the small farm and ranching community of Crosby, authorities said. Aerial footage showed a trailer carcass, its sides melted, burning in a flooded lot.
The Texas environmental agency called the smoke ‘especially acrid and irritating’ and said it can impair breathing and inflame the eyes, nose and throat.
Fifteen sheriff’s deputies complained of respiratory irritation. They were examined at a hospital and released.
The US Chemical Safety Board, an independent federal agency, launched an investigation into the accident.
‘This should be a wake-up call [for] all kinds of plants that are storing and converting reactive chemicals in areas which have high population densities,’ said Nicholas Ashford, a Massachusetts Institute of Technology expert.
The plant is along a corridor near Houston that contains one of the biggest concentrations of refineries, pipelines and chemical plants in the country.
Andrea Morrow, a spokeswoman for the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality, said the agency had not received any reports of trouble at other chemical plants in the hurricane-stricken zone.
The flooded plant is seen after fires were reported at the facility on Thursday, just days after Arkema officials had warned that an explosion was imminent
An Arkema executive warned that more explosions were expected in containers storing the highly unstable chemicals used in plastics
Texas A&M chemical safety expert Sam Mannan said the risk management plan that Arkema was required by state and federal law to develop did not address how it would deal with power and refrigeration failures or flooding in the event of a natural disaster like Harvey.
The catastrophic flooding that engulfed Houston in the days after Hurricane Harvey made landfall in Texas a week ago has resulted in 47 deaths, but that number is expected to rise.
‘Certainly we didn’t anticipate having six feet of water in our plant,’ Richard Rennard, an Arkema executive, said at a news conference Thursday. ‘And this is really the issue that led to the incident we are experiencing now.’
A 2016 analysis he did with university colleagues ranked the Crosby plant among the 70 or so facilities with the biggest potential to cause harm in greater Houston, based on such factors as the type and amount of chemicals and the population density.
Arkema, which is headquartered in France, did not immediately return calls on the plant’s contingency planning.
monomers, America for Arkema Inc, on Thursday the plant had been left without refrigeration for chemicals that become volatile as the temperature rises
Rachel Moreno, a spokeswoman for the fire marshal of Harris County, which encompasses Houston, would not discuss details of the risk management plan, such as how high the plant’s backup generators were placed.
Arkema officials did not directly notify local emergency managers of the generator failure, Moreno said. It came, instead, by way of the plant’s workers, who told the Crosby Volunteer Fire Department about it when they were rescued during the storm, she said.
Rennard said the chemical compounds were transferred to refrigerated containers after power was lost. But he said those containers failed too, causing the chemicals in one unit to burn. Rennard said more explosions were expected from the remaining containers.
State and federal regulators have cited Arkema for safety and environmental violations at the Crosby plant dating back more than a decade, records show.
Texas’ environmental commission penalized the company at least three times for a total of about $27,000, some of which was deferred pending corrective actions. Arkema denied the allegations.
During the last five years of compliance monitoring at the plant, state officials found five Clean Air Act-related deviations and two deviations from federal requirements on waste management, US Environmental Protection Agency records show.
In June 2006, the company had failed to prevent unauthorized emissions during a two-hour warehouse fire. Records show a pallet of organic peroxide was poorly stored, resulting in the blaze, and more than a ton of volatile organic compounds were discharged.
The biggest penalty, about $20,000, came in December 2011 after the commission found Arkema had failed to keep thermal oxidizers, used to decompose hazardous gases, at high enough temperatures over the course of several months.
Mike Cossey, of Bureau Veritas, uses an air monitor to check the quality of air at a police roadblock marking the 1.5-mile perimeter of the evacuation area around Arkema
Just outside Crosby, Texas, a convoy of about 30 emergency medical vehicles are parked on US Route 90, which state police had blocked off to eastbound traffic Thursday
A man talks with officers at a roadblock less than three miles from the Arkema Inc. chemical plant Thursday in Crosby
More recently, the US Occupational Safety and Health Administration in February fined Arkema nearly $110,000 – later reduced to just over $90,000 – because of 10 serious safety violations found during an inspection.
Records obtained by the AP show Arkema had kept using some equipment even when safety systems weren’t working properly, and didn’t inspect or test it as recommended. In one unit, the company also didn’t ensure equipment there was safe or keep employees up to date on their training.
Arkema is also embroiled in a series of lawsuits stemming from a deadly accident involving one of its contracts at a rail yard in New Orleans.
Arkema is defending itself in federal court after one worker died and two others were seriously injured when they were assigned to clean the inside of a rail car tank that had been filled with a harmful chemical. T
he men, who were working for a contractor with a long history of safety problems, were not wearing respirators and collapsed almost immediately, according to lawsuits filed by the survivors and the family of the man who died.
In court documents, Arkema denied responsibility for the accident, saying it had trusted its contractor to run the operation safely.