News, Culture & Society

Jurors using VR headsets to see the crime scene are 87% more likely to agree on a verdict

Virtual reality (VR) headsets could soon help jurors piece together a crime scene during a court trial by transporting them to the car accident or murder site.

Research at the University of South Australia (UniSA) unveiled a system that simulates the crime scene using laser scans, allowing jurors to move around the area and see specific evidence related to the crime.

To test the innovation, the team showed one group of mock jurors photographs of the crime scene and another used the 3D headset to investigate the same site.

Study participants viewing a deadly car accident through a 3D headset were 86.67 percent more chose  the same verdict, which was death by dangerous driving, while the other group was split 47/53 percent between a careless driving verdict and dangerous driving verdict.

 

Virtual reality (VR) headsets could soon help jurors piece together a crime scene during a court trail by transporting them to the car accident or murder site

Dr Andrew Cunningham, from UniSA’s Australian Research Centre for Interactive and Virtual Environments, said in a statement: ‘Participants who were immersed in the scene were more likely to correctly remember the location of the car in relation to the victim at the time of the accident, whereas it was difficult for people to visualize the scene from still images.

‘This provides unequivocal evidence that interactive technology leads to fairer and more consistent verdicts, and indeed could be the future of courtrooms.’

During the study, the team showed one group a baseline condition that included a slideshow of 32 images, 14 of which were a reconstruction of the crime scene and the rest were of the real event and evidence

The other group experienced the VR condition, which allowed users to ‘navigate the space by walking or using a standard teleportation method,’ according to the study published in the Proceedings of the 2021 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems.

To test the innovation, the team showed one group of mock jurors photographs of the crime scene and another used the 3D headset to investigate the same deadly car accident

To test the innovation, the team showed one group of mock jurors photographs of the crime scene and another used the 3D headset to investigate the same deadly car accident

Users can also see through different view points, this included the driver's and eye witnesses who saw the accident

Users can also see through different view points, this included the driver’s and eye witnesses who saw the accident

There are ‘hotspots’ throughout the digital world that shows photographs of evidence found at the real car accident.

Users can also see through different view points, this included the driver’s and eye witnesses who saw the accident.

‘Virtual reality also required significantly less effort than using photographs to piece together the sequence of events,’ said Cunningham.

Lead researcher Dr Carolin Reichherzer said site visits are still the gold standard in providing juries with a realistic impression of a scene, but they also have their drawbacks. ‘They are expensive—especially in remote locations—and in some cases the site itself has changed, making accurate viewings impossible,’ Dr Reichherzer said.

There are 'hotspots' throughout the digital world that shows photographs of evidence found at the real car accident

There are ‘hotspots’ throughout the digital world that shows photographs of evidence found at the real car accident

During the study, the team showed on group a baseline condition that included a slideshow of 32 images, 14 of which were a reconstruction of the crime scene and some were of the real event

During the study, the team showed on group a baseline condition that included a slideshow of 32 images, 14 of which were a reconstruction of the crime scene and some were of the real event

Although the Australian researchers are still working on their innovation, the technology has been used during a real court hearing.

In 2018, a Beijing No. 1 Intermediate People’s Court became the first court in China to introduce VR during a criminal case, VR Scout reports.

A HTC Vive headset was used to transport the only witness of a murder back to the scene with the hopes of helping them recall specific events.

The murder case, according to Chinese publication Legal Daily, involved a suspect named Zhang, 30 who was charged with the murder of his girlfriend, Liu, 19. 

Zhang allegedly stabbed his girlfriend to death on September 13, 2017 after he cut himself with a knife three times.

The witness, named in court as Mou Dong, used the headset while in the middle of the court, but was dropped back into the horrifying scene that was also played on a projector  for jurors, the judge and lawyers to see.

‘I was standing behind Liu at that time. Zhang was asking something from Liu. And then he started to injure himself,’ said Dong, the victim’s colleague, while using the Vive controllers to explore the simulated environment. 

Read more at DailyMail.co.uk