Practice reveals appointment waits were cut by 21% after adding a self-care note for colds on phone

Adding a simple message onto the end of GP phone lines on how to self-care for a cold could cut waiting times, a study suggests. 

One practice in Scotland saw the wait for routine appointments drop by 21 per cent after patients decided they no longer needed to see a doctor.

It comes as millions of patients are having to wait more than two weeks to see their GP amid a staffing crisis that is hurting the NHS from all sides.

Family doctors are retiring early or leaving because of workload pressures from mounting practice lists and an ageing population. 

The ten areas in England where patients have to wait at least two weeks to see their GP after calling. Figures are for February 2019, published by NHS Digital

Teviot Medical Practice in Hawick, Roxburghshire, added a message to its telephone system last winter, when demand on GPs is known to spike.

The automated clip, played to callers between November 2017 and March 2018, gave advice taken from the NHS Inform website.

Researchers, led by Dr Robin Kerr at the practice, counted the amount of callers who stayed on the line to speak to a receptionist.

WHAT ADVICE FOR THE COMMON COLD DOES THE PHONE MESSAGE GIVE? 

The message played to patients calling Teviot Medical Practice in Hawick, Scotland, follows:

Many people in the area currently have a cold. It’s very common and usually clears up on its own within a week or two.

The main symptoms of a cold include:

a sore throat

a blocked or runny nose

sneezing

a cough

There’s no cure for a cold, but you can look after yourself at home by:

resting, drinking plenty of fluids and eating healthily

taking over-the-counter painkillers, such as paracetamol or ibuprofen, to reduce any fever or discomfort

using decongestant sprays or tablets to relieve a blocked nose

You only really need to contact your GP if:

your symptoms persist for more than three weeks

your symptoms get suddenly worse

you have breathing difficulties

you develop complications of a cold, such as chest pain or coughing up bloodstained mucus

Source: NHS Inform

They compared the numbers to previous data and found that they received 5.5 per cent less routine calls when the clip was played.

The wait for a routine appointment dropped by 21 per cent, with the mean wait time for the ‘third available routine appointment’ reducing to 3.5 days from 4.42 days in the previous year.

Dr Kerr said: ‘This [study] strongly infers that the telephone announcements reduce demand for GP appointments.

‘This study has demonstrated that the use of telephone announcements signposting appropriate patients with the common cold in the direction of community pharmacy or self-management reduces calls navigating to speak to a receptionist.’

The findings were revealed in the British Medical Journal publication Innovations. 

Around seven per cent of problems taken to a GP can be dealt with at home or with a pharmacist, the doctors said.

Following their research, the doctors at Teviot Medical Practice said: ‘The authors encourage interested GPs to implement this intervention in their own practices to help improve self-management, reduce seasonal demand and improve patient access.’ 

This could be a more appropriate action amid the spiralling waiting times to see a GP seen across the country.

Around 3.8million patients were unable to see their GP within two weeks during February, the most recent NHS Digital data shows.

More than 920,000 are having to wait between three to four weeks for an appointment, with some parts of the country fairing worse than others. 

A simple message on the end of GP phone lines on how to self-care for a cold could cut soaring waiting times, findings from one surgery in Scotland suggests

A simple message on the end of GP phone lines on how to self-care for a cold could cut soaring waiting times, findings from one surgery in Scotland suggests

WHAT TEN CCGS HAVE THE HIGHEST NUMBER OF PATIENTS WAITING TWO WEEKS?

Swindon – 27.54%

Newark and Sherwood – 26.09%

South Norfolk – 24.21%

Isle of Wight – 24.06%

South West Lincolnshire – 23.99%

North Norfolk – 23.61%

Darlington – 23.43%

Greater Huddersfield – 23.06%

Horsham and Mid Sussex – 22.77%

North Derbyshire 22.26% 

In the Swindon CCG area, almost a third (27.54 per cent) of patients didn’t see their doctor for at least 14 days after trying to book.

Chronic shortages of staff in places such as GP surgeries is jeopardising quality of care and waiting times, with staff numbers failing to keep pace with demand. 

More than 1,000 GPs have left the NHS since 2015, and official figures in February showed that a further 10,000 are expected to quit in the next five to ten years because they are 50 or over.

Almost a fifth (18 per cent) said they would leave or retire within the next two years, blaming unmanageable workloads and increased demands from an ageing population. 

Pressures faced by doctors also include a rising number of patients, some with multiple complex health conditions.

This has led to concerns that the average consultation time of 10 minutes in the UK – thought to be the shortest in the developed world – is simply not enough. 

Doctors are also avoiding working extra shifts or leaving the profession early in a bid to avoid hefty tax bills on their pension.

More than 3,500 doctors retired early to avoid bills of thousands of pounds on capped pension saving allowances, the Government said this week. 

The complexity of the crisis is expected to put 762 practices in the UK at risk of closing within the next five years, according to The Royal College of General Practitioners. 

More than 2.5million patients across England could see their GP surgeries close in the next five years, experts revealed in November. 

Overall, NHS staff shortages in England have hit more than 100,000 positions, according to three think tanks, the King’s Fund, the Health Foundation, and the Nuffield Trust. 

They predict that the situation could increase to almost a quarter of a million by 2030 if not dealt with.

HOW MANY PATIENTS IN YOUR AREA HAD TO WAIT MORE THAN TWO WEEKS? 
CCG Total appointments Same day 8 TO 14 DAYS 15 TO 21 DAYS 22 TO 28 DAYS <28 DAYS TOTAL > 14 DAYS % > 14 DAYS
England 23,077,849 9,772,483 3,312,613 1,763,295 1,167,847 921,658 3,852,800 16.7%
NHS Darlington CCG 46,941 15,779 6,926 4,422 3,400 3,175 10,997 23.43%
NHS Durham Dales, Easington and Sedgefield CCG 161,402 61,815 27,579 10,348 5,326 4,032 19,706 12.21%
NHS North Durham CCG 130,351 58,319 19,031 8,782 4,942 4,014 17,738 13.61%
NHS Hartlepool and Stockton-on-Tees CCG 118,270 45,444 19,440 8,511 5,349 4,408 18,268 15.45%
NHS Northumberland CCG 160,989 74,231 20,606 12,852 7,763 7,427 28,042 17.42%
NHS South Tees CCG 140,808 60,853 18,503 9,273 6,501 6,928 22,702 16.12%
NHS South Tyneside CCG 60,054 22,948 7,953 3,948 2,384 1,825 8,157 13.58%
NHS Sunderland CCG 114,679 42,109 19,534 7,455 5,023 4,338 16,816 14.66%
NHS Blackburn with Darwen CCG 60,542 24,718 9,119 3,548 2,039 1,461 7,048 11.64%
NHS Blackpool CCG 77,238 28,665 11,989 6,316 4,979 2,285 13,580 17.58%
NHS Bolton CCG 96,903 39,888 14,365 6,563 4,247 3,103 13,913 14.36%
NHS Chorley and South Ribble CCG 64,904 24,809 9,683 5,461 3,782 4,024 13,267 20.44%
NHS Oldham CCG 101,976 42,659 15,177 8,242 6,653 4,350 19,245 18.87%
NHS East Lancashire CCG 142,274 58,246 21,924 11,259 8,224 5,684 25,167 17.69%
NHS Eastern Cheshire CCG 75,281 29,480 12,400 6,226 3,849 3,052 13,127 17.44%
NHS Heywood, Middleton and Rochdale CCG 96,219 36,836 15,079 8,299 4,993 3,710 17,002 17.67%
NHS Greater Preston CCG 62,111 25,599 9,862 5,406 3,296 1,953 10,655 17.15%
NHS Halton CCG 56,182 27,975 6,241 3,804 2,842 1,794 8,440 15.02%
NHS Salford CCG 45,571 20,139 5,985 3,827 2,664 1,746 8,237 18.08%
NHS North Cumbria CCG 162,068 69,837 21,912 11,103 7,467 6,520 25,090 15.48%
NHS Knowsley CCG 71,005 31,868 10,479 3,601 1,852 1,295 6,748 9.50%
NHS Morecambe Bay CCG 143,149 52,803 21,659 10,801 9,062 7,531 27,394 19.14%
NHS South Cheshire CCG 74,740 28,128 11,697 6,890 4,722 3,026 14,638 19.59%
NHS South Sefton CCG 48,437 22,275 7,968 2,615 1,147 829 4,591 9.48%
NHS Southport and Formby CCG 49,029 21,304 6,516 3,605 2,169 1,953 7,727 15.76%
NHS Stockport CCG 115,478 45,709 19,514 10,201 6,470 3,995 20,666 17.90%
NHS St Helens CCG 71,551 32,541 9,671 5,361 3,763 1,769 10,893 15.22%
NHS Tameside and Glossop CCG 107,559 41,022 15,619 10,537 7,607 4,687 22,831 21.23%
NHS Trafford CCG 76,625 30,750 12,968 5,855 3,722 3,671 13,248 17.29%
NHS Vale Royal CCG 39,597 18,352 6,334 3,425 1,800 839 6,064 15.31%
NHS Warrington CCG 79,159 37,251 10,557 5,959 3,467 3,252 12,678 16.02%
NHS West Cheshire CCG 106,283 45,212 17,031 6,894 4,596 3,332 14,822 13.95%
NHS West Lancashire CCG 42,456 14,708 7,263 3,406 1,799 1,388 6,593 15.53%
NHS Wigan Borough CCG 106,636 40,318 15,476 7,388 5,042 3,662 16,092 15.09%
NHS Fylde and Wyre CCG 78,416 32,692 9,118 6,138 5,858 4,486 16,482 21.02%
NHS Airedale, Wharfedale and Craven CCG 85,345 41,616 10,255 6,071 4,402 4,653 15,126 17.72%
NHS Barnsley CCG 113,516 44,054 17,862 10,692 5,261 5,136 21,089 18.58%
NHS Bassetlaw CCG 55,305 27,722 6,017 3,795 3,451 3,337 10,583 19.14%
NHS Bradford Districts CCG 168,945 74,073 20,477 12,470 9,433 12,469 34,372 20.35%
NHS Calderdale CCG 96,772 42,242 11,171 8,302 5,851 4,963 19,116 19.75%
NHS Bradford City CCG 66,656 34,685 7,410 3,620 2,008 2,663 8,291 12.44%
NHS Doncaster CCG 147,129 64,500 21,330 9,521 5,208 5,226 19,955 13.56%
NHS East Riding of Yorkshire CCG 125,169 48,399 20,047 9,736 7,366 7,499 24,601 19.65%
NHS Greater Huddersfield CCG 100,647 39,534 13,574 9,404 6,293 7,509 23,206 23.06%
NHS Hambleton, Richmondshire and Whitby CCG 66,353 25,156 9,825 4,503 3,664 3,012 11,179 16.85%
NHS Harrogate and Rural District CCG 71,936 29,993 9,734 5,763 4,134 3,534 13,431 18.67%
NHS Hull CCG 110,539 41,810 19,187 9,656 6,755 3,806 20,217 18.29%
NHS North East Lincolnshire CCG 88,750 41,529 11,417 7,243 3,966 2,874 14,083 15.87%
NHS North Kirklees CCG 84,551 33,672 10,227 6,013 3,910 4,397 14,320 16.94%
NHS North Lincolnshire CCG 83,421 36,524 11,696 5,685 4,007 3,455 13,147 15.76%
NHS Rotherham CCG 124,440 47,454 18,621 10,042 6,231 5,529 21,802 17.52%
NHS Scarborough and Ryedale CCG 61,458 21,565 9,046 5,423 3,478 4,147 13,048 21.23%
NHS Sheffield CCG 278,359 115,171 38,275 23,824 17,934 19,380 61,138 21.96%
NHS Vale of York CCG 142,231 51,630 25,150 14,033 8,207 4,612 26,852 18.88%
NHS Wakefield CCG 189,447 88,314 21,379 12,721 9,807 10,056 32,584 17.20%
NHS Lincolnshire East CCG 118,030 51,040 19,239 10,080 7,091 6,072 23,243 19.69%
NHS Corby CCG 31,727 12,305 5,956 2,390 953 938 4,281 13.49%
NHS East Leicestershire and Rutland CCG 162,314 67,299 24,027 11,875 7,761 7,007 26,643 16.41%
NHS Erewash CCG 44,292 16,085 7,309 4,101 2,679 2,304 9,084 20.51%
NHS Hardwick CCG 56,177 22,434 8,692 4,675 4,088 3,114 11,877 21.14%
NHS Leicester City CCG 170,751 72,531 23,798 11,025 7,906 8,063 26,994 15.81%
NHS Lincolnshire West CCG 89,859 35,589 13,045 9,019 5,236 3,787 18,042 20.08%
NHS Mansfield and Ashfield CCG 89,442 38,776 11,735 7,795 5,753 5,748 19,296 21.57%
NHS Milton Keynes CCG 120,674 47,454 16,823 10,590 6,971 7,393 24,954 20.68%
NHS Nene CCG 297,794 137,075 38,006 20,121 14,772 12,992 47,885 16.08%
NHS Newark and Sherwood CCG 60,390 23,102 7,838 5,896 5,609 4,253 15,758 26.09%
NHS North Derbyshire CCG 143,447 53,401 21,448 11,699 9,331 10,906 31,936 22.26%
NHS Nottingham City CCG 153,740 65,782 23,483 10,579 7,342 6,054 23,975 15.59%
NHS Nottingham North and East CCG 64,299 26,105 8,246 4,961 4,290 3,670 12,921 20.10%
NHS Nottingham West CCG 48,633 18,814 6,564 4,070 3,084 2,413 9,567 19.67%
NHS Rushcliffe CCG 63,676 24,894 9,993 5,271 3,880 3,364 12,515 19.65%
NHS South West Lincolnshire CCG 61,335 22,374 9,269 7,014 4,542 3,159 14,715 23.99%
NHS Southern Derbyshire CCG 234,230 97,655 32,515 18,873 14,999 14,612 48,484 20.70%
NHS West Leicestershire CCG 182,968 78,458 26,134 14,776 11,222 10,366 36,364 19.87%
NHS Cannock Chase CCG 50,624 19,639 8,763 4,657 2,243 1,259 8,159 16.12%
NHS Coventry and Rugby CCG 170,533 79,176 22,989 10,404 5,435 3,933 19,772 11.59%
NHS Dudley CCG 128,031 50,082 18,186 11,211 7,503 5,273 23,987 18.74%
NHS East Staffordshire CCG 45,755 19,580 6,166 2,925 1,907 1,793 6,625 14.48%
NHS Herefordshire CCG 89,176 38,014 13,811 8,562 5,774 3,094 17,430 19.55%
NHS North Staffordshire CCG 78,988 33,452 11,959 5,441 2,767 1,621 9,829 12.44%
NHS Warwickshire North CCG 26,608 13,820 3,748 1,556 871 774 3,201 12.03%
NHS Redditch and Bromsgrove CCG 78,444 30,121 11,308 6,045 3,950 2,591 12,586 16.04%
NHS Sandwell and West Birmingham CCG 242,117 115,784 29,476 12,208 7,251 7,888 27,347 11.29%
NHS Shropshire CCG 133,975 55,123 21,142 10,835 7,568 3,572 21,975 16.40%
NHS South East Staffordshire and Seisdon Peninsula CCG 87,749 34,006 12,642 7,359 5,618 3,008 15,985 18.22%
NHS South Warwickshire CCG 136,072 64,204 17,404 7,788 4,962 4,107 16,857 12.39%
NHS South Worcestershire CCG 132,096 58,075 19,319 10,332 7,187 4,903 22,422 16.97%
NHS Stafford and Surrounds CCG 63,709 28,827 9,542 4,866 3,373 2,706 10,945 17.18%
NHS Stoke on Trent CCG 99,122 40,969 15,411 8,292 3,074 2,318 13,684 13.81%
NHS Telford and Wrekin CCG 76,045 34,610 11,998 5,350 2,103 1,258 8,711 11.46%
NHS Walsall CCG 125,595 45,343 22,046 9,595 5,386 4,680 19,661 15.65%
NHS Wolverhampton CCG 98,687 36,984 17,023 7,624 3,979 4,356 15,959 16.17%
NHS Wyre Forest CCG 71,905 36,849 7,264 3,287 2,640 2,734 8,661 12.05%
NHS Bedfordshire CCG 200,572 83,845 25,891 17,542 14,921 11,310 43,773 21.82%
NHS Cambridgeshire and Peterborough CCG 453,862 217,717 59,077 29,816 19,329 17,406 66,551 14.66%
NHS East and North Hertfordshire CCG 210,089 89,104 29,670 18,653 12,258 11,438 42,349 20.16%
NHS Ipswich and East Suffolk CCG 189,683 89,122 22,376 14,119 9,821 10,749 34,689 18.29%
NHS Great Yarmouth and Waveney CCG 108,007 47,178 14,011 8,981 6,773 4,910 20,664 19.13%
NHS Herts Valleys CCG 210,771 85,959 33,029 15,883 9,852 5,718 31,453 14.92%
NHS Luton CCG 86,199 36,154 12,253 7,117 4,281 3,724 15,122 17.54%
NHS Mid Essex CCG 157,406 64,633 22,643 13,517 9,576 7,410 30,503 19.38%
NHS North East Essex CCG 155,357 68,714 20,495 11,779 8,385 6,093 26,257 16.90%
NHS North Norfolk CCG 90,659 33,468 13,215 8,147 7,647 5,611 21,405 23.61%
NHS Norwich CCG 108,218 47,979 13,681 9,276 7,509 5,693 22,478 20.77%
NHS South Norfolk CCG 106,844 42,689 13,827 10,124 9,158 6,582 25,864 24.21%
NHS Thurrock CCG 71,351 32,380 9,330 4,003 2,524 1,521 8,048 11.28%
NHS West Essex CCG 110,745 51,133 14,931 9,126 6,071 4,193 19,390 17.51%
NHS West Norfolk CCG 95,696 39,029 13,306 7,643 6,120 6,746 20,509 21.43%
NHS West Suffolk CCG 113,141 50,816 15,111 8,720 5,617 2,911 17,248 15.24%
NHS Barking and Dagenham CCG 62,497 25,588 9,129 4,867 2,062 789 7,718 12.35%
NHS Barnet CCG 108,043 53,235 14,196 6,690 4,997 2,997 14,684 13.59%
NHS Bexley CCG 18,618 6,663 3,747 1,585 1,087 547 3,219 17.29%
NHS Brent CCG 134,726 55,000 22,355 9,942 3,777 1,604 15,323 11.37%
NHS Bromley CCG 105,224 43,042 15,300 8,986 4,878 3,005 16,869 16.03%
NHS Camden CCG 82,677 35,112 11,902 6,592 3,527 1,847 11,966 14.47%
NHS City and Hackney CCG 125,521 65,471 12,670 6,288 3,050 1,637 10,975 8.74%
NHS Croydon CCG 135,715 58,788 19,566 7,749 5,209 2,641 15,599 11.49%
NHS Ealing CCG 173,220 72,205 24,834 12,127 6,089 3,746 21,962 12.68%
NHS Enfield CCG 98,598 43,048 14,351 8,889 3,685 1,916 14,490 14.70%
NHS Hounslow CCG 120,893 43,801 19,865 10,401 5,249 3,191 18,841 15.58%
NHS Greenwich CCG 27,858 12,886 4,593 1,989 642 315 2,946 10.58%
NHS Hammersmith and Fulham CCG 80,336 30,862 11,340 5,205 3,424 2,241 10,870 13.53%
NHS Haringey CCG 88,737 40,088 12,422 6,300 2,935 1,120 10,355 11.67%
NHS Harrow CCG 97,517 36,418 16,057 7,594 3,387 2,154 13,135 13.47%
NHS Havering CCG 74,363 27,103 13,022 6,801 4,238 2,492 13,531 18.20%
NHS Hillingdon CCG 99,117 41,338 17,011 7,820 2,877 1,464 12,161 12.27%
NHS Islington CCG 84,156 39,226 11,550 6,168 4,132 2,296 12,596 14.97%
NHS Kingston CCG 60,768 28,915 8,443 4,472 2,285 1,304 8,061 13.27%
NHS Lambeth CCG 139,722 61,714 20,562 8,191 3,920 1,880 13,991 10.01%
NHS Lewisham CCG 107,280 47,608 16,461 5,961 3,778 1,841 11,580 10.79%
NHS Newham CCG 132,289 57,277 19,600 8,735 4,521 2,407 15,663 11.84%
NHS Redbridge CCG 100,397 45,271 14,280 7,318 3,090 1,442 11,850 11.80%
NHS Richmond CCG 19,784 7,951 3,038 1,661 822 361 2,844 14.38%
NHS Southwark CCG 115,088 48,072 19,266 8,849 4,789 1,632 15,270 13.27%
NHS Merton CCG 68,519 32,869 10,334 3,914 1,816 935 6,665 9.73%
NHS Sutton CCG 73,226 33,058 10,445 4,169 2,328 1,837 8,334 11.38%
NHS Tower Hamlets CCG 132,425 54,332 19,341 9,221 4,740 2,770 16,731 12.63%
NHS Waltham Forest CCG 101,512 46,144 15,948 6,253 2,159 715 9,127 8.99%
NHS Wandsworth CCG 143,292 61,308 20,965 9,635 4,847 2,485 16,967 11.84%
NHS West London CCG 93,932 38,115 13,442 6,059 2,534 1,752 10,345 11.01%
NHS Central London (Westminster) CCG 75,147 30,434 12,263 6,147 3,687 2,395 12,229 16.27%
NHS Ashford CCG 68,100 35,303 7,839 4,153 2,372 2,219 8,744 12.84%
NHS Brighton and Hove CCG 111,255 49,877 15,221 6,884 3,991 3,613 14,488 13.02%
NHS Canterbury and Coastal CCG 107,005 45,907 15,573 9,086 5,316 4,586 18,988 17.74%
NHS Eastbourne, Hailsham and Seaford CCG 100,525 44,033 14,118 7,155 4,976 5,378 17,509 17.42%
NHS Coastal West Sussex CCG 239,843 103,208 32,516 19,869 13,697 11,586 45,152 18.83%
NHS Crawley CCG 55,744 25,655 7,951 5,185 3,595 1,955 10,735 19.26%
NHS Dartford, Gravesham and Swanley CCG 3,393 1,057 597 192 87 64 343 10.11%
NHS East Surrey CCG 74,599 28,814 11,842 6,206 4,316 2,729 13,251 17.76%
NHS Guildford and Waverley CCG 79,406 29,792 11,061 5,644 4,432 3,683 13,759 17.33%
NHS Hastings and Rother CCG 91,851 40,130 12,124 5,567 3,772 4,484 13,823 15.05%
NHS Medway CCG 79,671 35,665 10,900 6,984 5,047 2,536 14,567 18.28%
NHS Horsham and Mid Sussex CCG 88,491 34,274 11,803 7,674 6,287 6,184 20,145 22.77%
NHS North West Surrey CCG 127,546 52,964 18,596 11,143 7,466 6,218 24,827 19.47%
NHS South Kent Coast CCG 42,532 18,993 6,082 3,008 2,032 1,641 6,681 15.71%
NHS Surrey Heath CCG 43,405 18,798 5,570 3,274 1,928 1,168 6,370 14.68%
NHS Swale CCG 41,014 17,791 4,813 3,566 3,115 2,419 9,100 22.19%
NHS Thanet CCG 56,793 24,381 8,907 5,005 2,723 2,201 9,929 17.48%
NHS North Hampshire CCG 95,650 42,836 11,985 7,475 5,699 2,519 15,693 16.41%
NHS Fareham and Gosport CCG 83,862 31,787 14,023 8,721 7,140 2,781 18,642 22.23%
NHS Isle of Wight CCG 71,158 24,513 10,327 5,599 5,211 6,312 17,122 24.06%
NHS Oxfordshire CCG 304,843 126,526 44,368 23,140 16,180 11,075 50,395 16.53%
NHS Portsmouth CCG 86,062 40,329 11,915 8,279 4,885 2,105 15,269 17.74%
NHS South Eastern Hampshire CCG 85,175 39,441 12,915 6,324 4,042 2,811 13,177 15.47%
NHS Southampton CCG 114,782 47,984 18,169 7,900 5,451 4,131 17,482 15.23%
NHS West Hampshire CCG 214,219 89,881 30,982 19,844 14,403 9,294 43,541 20.33%
NHS Bath and North East Somerset CCG 93,668 38,859 13,560 7,889 4,593 3,970 16,452 17.56%
NHS Dorset CCG 359,596 130,480 56,563 31,178 21,505 22,669 75,352 20.95%
NHS Gloucestershire CCG 258,594 99,159 39,718 23,455 16,651 13,856 53,962 20.87%
NHS Kernow CCG 152,760 64,505 21,921 12,315 10,009 6,837 29,161 19.09%
NHS Somerset CCG 223,084 94,603 30,878 17,084 12,313 9,297 38,694 17.35%
NHS Swindon CCG 102,025 36,560 15,070 11,635 8,572 7,890 28,097 27.54%
NHS Wirral CCG 145,532 58,248 21,776 9,052 7,958 4,436 21,446 14.74%
NHS Newcastle Gateshead CCG 206,656 82,334 28,953 18,412 13,183 7,549 39,144 18.94%
NHS Manchester CCG 224,573 102,703 31,466 19,520 12,925 8,174 40,619 18.09%
NHS Buckinghamshire CCG 199,274 94,927 24,929 13,806 8,473 7,479 29,758 14.93%
NHS Berkshire West 154,762 69,331 20,921 12,593 8,539 4,579 25,711 16.61%
NHS Bristol, North Somerset and South Gloucestershire CCG 432,571 185,410 62,127 30,349 21,212 14,112 65,673 15.18%
NHS East Berkshire CCG 158,784 72,627 21,214 10,449 5,601 4,195 20,245 12.75%
NHS Birmingham and Solihull CCG 518,489 226,652 75,885 34,519 21,521 16,021 72,061 13.90%
NHS Leeds CCG 388,798 163,482 56,649 34,511 21,337 16,694 72,542 18.66%
NHS Liverpool CCG 205,012 112,139 22,471 10,655 7,629 3,335 21,619 10.55%
NHS North Tyneside CCG 89,306 33,477 16,334 7,501 4,154 4,077 15,732 17.62%
NHS South Lincolnshire CCG 84,210 41,724 10,945 5,710 4,007 4,321 14,038 16.67%
NHS Basildon and Brentwood CCG 102,606 42,934 14,449 7,968 5,397 4,726 18,091 17.63%
NHS Castle Point and Rochford CCG 63,167 24,401 10,639 5,166 3,014 2,509 10,689 16.92%
NHS Southend CCG 63,881 26,856 10,695 4,606 1,813 1,264 7,683 12.03%
NHS Surrey Downs CCG 113,190 43,778 16,909 8,991 6,174 5,998 21,163 18.70%
NHS West Kent CCG 113,417 43,992 17,278 9,421 5,938 5,547 20,906 18.43%
NHS High Weald Lewes Havens CCG 71,206 29,883 10,269 5,502 3,082 4,338 12,922 18.15%
NHS North East Hampshire and Farnham CCG 83,010 32,026 14,931 7,667 4,360 2,896 14,923 17.98%
NHS Wiltshire CCG 247,778 102,594 36,748 18,785 14,307 13,329 46,421 18.73%
NHS Northern, Eastern and Western Devon CCG 462,320 187,717 63,651 34,296 25,715 21,866 81,877 17.71%
NHS South Devon and Torbay CCG 167,998 77,525 22,128 11,374 8,034 6,345 25,753 15.33%

Read more at DailyMail.co.uk