Steve Smith and David Warner are facing life bans over ball tampering scandal

Steve Smith is facing a life ban from cricket for cheating, despite escaping with a one-match suspension after admitting to ball tampering.

Cricket Australia’s Head of Integrity Iain Roy has begun interviewing players in South Africa as part of a ‘full investigation’ into the cheating scandal.

Code of behaviour charges are expected to follow, leading to a verdict by an independent commissioner who could impose the maximum penalty of a life ban on both Smith and David Warner for conduct contrary to the spirit of the game. 

 

Steve Smith (pictured with his fiancee Dani Willis) could be facing a life ban from cricket for cheating, despite escaping with a one-match suspension after admitting to ball tampering

Cricket Australia's Head of Integrity Iain Roy has begun interviewing players in South Africa as part of a 'full investigation' into the cheating scandal (pictured are David Warner with his wife Candice Warner)

Cricket Australia’s Head of Integrity Iain Roy has begun interviewing players in South Africa as part of a ‘full investigation’ into the cheating scandal (pictured are David Warner with his wife Candice Warner)

Cricket legend Shane Warne weighed into the scandal in commentary, and said Steve Smith may never captain Australia again (pictured is Cameron Bancroft)

Cricket legend Shane Warne weighed into the scandal in commentary, and said Steve Smith may never captain Australia again (pictured is Cameron Bancroft)

Shane Warne said in commentary he could not see Smith returning as team leader, and Tim Paine should lead the team until a long-term replacement is found (pictured is Cameron Bancroft holding a piece of sandpaper)

Shane Warne said in commentary he could not see Smith returning as team leader, and Tim Paine should lead the team until a long-term replacement is found (pictured is Cameron Bancroft holding a piece of sandpaper)

'The other thing which I know it will be really hard for a lot of people and will take a lot of time, and I accept that, but forgiveness,' said Clarke on the Today show (pictured is Smith after he was stood down)

‘The other thing which I know it will be really hard for a lot of people and will take a lot of time, and I accept that, but forgiveness,’ said Clarke on the Today show (pictured is Smith after he was stood down)

Smith’s predecessor Michael Clarke took a softer line on the embattled captain, and said on Monday morning he should be forgiven.

‘The other thing which I know it will be really hard for a lot of people and will take a lot of time, and I accept that, but forgiveness,’ said Clarke on the Today show.

‘I do feel for Steve Smith. 100 per cent he has made a major mistake. Him, and I think a lot of people, will have to suffer the consequences, and I think that’s fair enough.

‘I think that’s fair enough, but I think it is important that we do, over time, forgive as well.’ 

Smith's predecessor Michael Clarke (pictured) took a softer line on the embattled captain, and said on Monday morning he should be forgiven

Smith’s predecessor Michael Clarke (pictured) took a softer line on the embattled captain, and said on Monday morning he should be forgiven

Clarke went on to say he hopes Smith is not surrounded by paparazzi on his return to Australia, and is able to leave his home without being stared at. 

Cricket legend Shane Warne weighed into the scandal in commentary, and said Steve Smith may never captain Australia again.

Shane Warne said in commentary he could not see Smith returning as team leader, and Tim Paine should lead the team until a long-term replacement is found.

‘You’d have to say it’s in real jeopardy as to whether he’ll ever captain again,’ Warne said as Australia crashed to a 322-run defeat in the Third Test against South Africa.

Steve Smith (left) and David Warner (right) have been removed as captain and vice-captain of the Australian cricket team

Steve Smith (left) and David Warner (right) have been removed as captain and vice-captain of the Australian cricket team

‘I think Paine will be the interim, but not for the long term and then they’ll work out just who is the best option for them.’ 

Despite his scathing assessment of Smith’s future, Warne said he and vice-captain David Warner should have been able to finish the Test, and not sacked halfway through.

‘I don’t think it’s the right thing Smith and Warner should be stood down during the match. Wait until the end of the Test match,’ he said.

‘At the end of the Test, if you want to get them out of the team and sack them as captain and vice captain, that’s fine, but not during the Test match.’  

Cricket Australia made the announcement about Smith ahead of the fourth day's play in Cape Town on Sunday

Cricket Australia made the announcement about Smith ahead of the fourth day’s play in Cape Town on Sunday

WHO DID WHAT IN AUSTRALIA’S BALL-TAMPERING SCANDAL?

Exactly who did what?

Rookie opener Cameron Bancroft has been fined 75 per cent of his match fee and handed three demerit points by the International Cricket Council after being charged with attempting to change the condition of the ball, contravening Law 41.3.

He admitted doing so by using some sticky tape from the team’s kit bag, sticking “granules” from the pitch to it and using it as an abrasive surface to scuff the ball in pursuit of reverse swing.

Captain Steve Smith said he and the “leadership group” had discussed and agreed the action. He stood down for the rest of the Test along with vice-captain David Warner, was handed a one-match suspension by the ICC and fined 100 per cent of his match fee.

Who else was in this leadership group?

Smith did not expand on that, but in the past Australia have indicated senior bowlers Mitchell Starc and Josh Hazlewood were part of their decision-making unit. Tim Paine’s promotion as temporary skipper seems to absolve him. Head coach Darren Lehmann is an obvious authority figure but Smith insists he was not involved on this occasion.

Does that check out?

Lehmann did appear to speak to 12th man Peter Handscomb via walkie-talkie after TV images caught Bancroft red-handed. Handscomb later spoke to Bancroft, who proceeded to hide the tape down the front of his trousers. Explanations will be required.

Why was no on-field sanction taken?

First of all, Bancroft appeared to deceive the umpires by showing them the holder for his sunglasses instead of his ad-hoc sandpaper. Secondly, his attempts to change the ball simply appeared to be unsuccessful. The umpires looked at the ball and did not take the chance to replace it. Had they done so they could have levied five penalty runs against Australia.

Do they deserve some credit for fronting up?

Not particularly. Even after their plot was uncovered by cameras they made a clear attempt to put the officials off the scent on the field. Only after their guilt was established beyond any serious doubt did Smith and Bancroft appear before the media. Others may not have faced the music quite like that, but others may not have put themselves in that position in the first place.

How has Australia’s recent behaviour been other than this?

To sum up, they are not a popular bunch. They are regarded as the game’s most inveterate, though far from only, sledgers. Despite this they have attempted to position themselves as guardians of “the line” – a concept they used against South Africa in this ill-tempered series. Their reaction to England’s disciplinary lapses in the Ashes – notably when Bancroft and Smith gave a jovial press conference on the subject of Jonny Bairstow’s ‘headbutt’ greeting – saw them lobbing rocks from a sizeable glass house.

Have they done this before?

Smith was quick to emphasise this was a regrettable first-time offence but scepticism is natural. It could be argued previous transgressions would have been picked up in just the way this one was, but that is unlikely to prevent people poring over footage of recent series, including the Ashes.

By Rory Dollard, Press Association Sport 

In his post-match press conference Paine admitted the team was ‘struggling with the enormity’ of the ball tampering scandal that erupted on Sunday.

‘It has been a horrible 24 hours. We’re struggling but the reality and the enormity of what’s happened has probably started to sink in,’ Paine said.

‘I don’t think we expected this to be as big as it has been, the fall-out we have seen from back home.’

Smith was stood down as captain by Cricket Australia, and received a one-Test ban from the ICC along with 100 per cent of his match fee for the Third Test. 

Batsman Cameron Bancroft was caught tampering with ball against South Africa on Saturday

Batsman Cameron Bancroft was caught tampering with ball against South Africa on Saturday

Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull said the incident was wrong and called for decisive action from Cricket Australia

Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull said the incident was wrong and called for decisive action from Cricket Australia

Tim Paine was named as the acting captain following the decision after Smith and Warner ‘agreed to stand down’.

Cricket Australia called an emergency meeting to decide Smith’s future after Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull added his voice to the furious chorus demanding the skipper be stood down.

Cricket Australia chief executive, James Sutherland said: ‘Following discussions with Steve Smith and David Warner they have agreed to stand down as captain and vice-captain respectively for the remainder of this Test match.

‘This Test match needs to proceed, and in the interim we will continue to investigate this matter with the urgency that it demands.

Warner (left) and Smith (right) are both on the field for Australia against South Africa

Warner (left) and Smith (right) are both on the field for Australia against South Africa

Australia's Cameron Bancroft has found himself at the centre of ball-tampering controversy

Australia’s Cameron Bancroft has found himself at the centre of ball-tampering controversy

He was seen running his hand over the ball, before removing a yellow object from his pocket

The Australia player was then spotted putting the object down the front of his trousers

The opening batsman was seen running his hand over the ball, before removing a yellow object from his pocket and placing it down the front of his trousers

‘As I said earlier today, Cricket Australia and Australian cricket fans expect certain standards of conduct from cricketers representing our country, and on this occasion these standards have not been met.

‘All Australians, like us, want answers and we will keep you updated on our findings, as a matter of priority.’

David Peever, the chairman of Cricket Australia, said Tim Paine had been selected as the stand-in to replace Smith for the rest of the match in Cape Town. 

‘Both Steve and David will take to the field today under Tim’s captaincy,’ Mr Peever said.

Steve Smith (right) faced the media on Saturday night but has been removed as captain ahead of the fourth day in Cape Town

Steve Smith (right) faced the media on Saturday night but has been removed as captain ahead of the fourth day in Cape Town

‘The Board fully supports the process for an immediate investigation into what occurred in Cape Town.

‘We regard this as a matter of the utmost seriousness and urgency. We will ensure we have all information available to make the right decisions for Australian Cricket.’

Turnbull was flooded with ‘shock and bitter disappointment’ upon hearing the Australian cricket team were caught ball tampering in South Africa with batsman Cameron Bancroft using dirt stuck to a piece of tape.

Speaking about the incident which has thrown Australian cricket into to chaos, the prime minister said: ‘It seemed completely beyond belief that the Australian cricket team had been involved in cheating.’

Australian cricket is a laughing stock after Cameron Bancroft insisted that he was in the wrong place at the wrong time when he was caught

Australian cricket is a laughing stock after Cameron Bancroft insisted that he was in the wrong place at the wrong time when he was caught

He said the news beggared belief with the players role models for millions around the country.

‘The whole nation who holds those who wear the baggy green up on a pedestal — about as high as you can get in Australia, higher than any politician that’s for sure — this is a shocking disappointment. 

‘It’s wrong and I look forward to Cricket Australia taking decisive action soon,’ he said.

Mr Turnbull said he had been in contact with the Cricket Australia chairman David Peever to express his disappointment ‘clearly and unequivocally’. 

Adam Gilchrist branded Australia a 'laughing stock of the world' after the incident in South Africa

Adam Gilchrist branded Australia a ‘laughing stock of the world’ after the incident in South Africa

Shane Warne said during coverage of the Test match on Fox Sports that 'you just can't do that', adding: 'I don't care who you are.'

Shane Warne said during coverage of the Test match on Fox Sports that ‘you just can’t do that’, adding: ‘I don’t care who you are.’

The Australian Sports Commission has called on Smith to be removed as captain.

In a statement, the government body which funds sport in Australia, said it condemns cheating and expects Australian athletes to ‘demonstrate unimpeachable integrity in representing our country’.

‘The Australian cricket team are iconic representatives of our country,’ the statement from chairman John Wylie and chief executive Kate Palmer said.

‘The example they set matters a great deal to Australia and to the thousands of young Australians playing or enjoying the sport of cricket and who look up to the national team as role models.

Bancroft was spoken to by English umpires Nigel Llong and Richard Illingworth on Saturday

Bancroft was spoken to by English umpires Nigel Llong and Richard Illingworth on Saturday

Bancroft admitted he had panicked when he was sighted on the screens in the stadium

Bancroft admitted he had panicked when he was sighted on the screens in the stadium

‘Given the admission by Australian captain Steve Smith, the ASC calls for him to be stood down immediately by Cricket Australia, along with any other members of the team leadership group or coaching staff who had prior awareness of, or involvement in, the plan to tamper with the ball.

‘This can occur while Cricket Australia completes a full investigation.’

A host of cricket legends have called for Australian captain Steve Smith to be sacked as skipper after he admitted the leadership had hatched a plan to cheat.

Adam Gilchrist branded Australia a ‘laughing stock of the world’ after Bancroft was caught on camera pulling sticky tape from his pocket and rubbing it on the ball to illegally gain an advantage.

England fans are revelling in the controversy currently shrouding the Australian cricket team

England fans are revelling in the controversy currently shrouding the Australian cricket team

Shane Warne said during coverage of the Test match on Fox Sports that ‘you just can’t do that’, adding: ‘I don’t care who you are.’

He later tweeted: ‘Very disappointed with the pictures I saw on our coverage here in Cape Town.

‘If proven the alleged ball tampering is what we all think it is – then I hope Steve Smith and Darren Lehmann do the press conference to clean this mess up.’

Former Australian batsman Simon Katich said Cricket Australia had ‘no choice’ but to sack Smith, vice-captain David Warner and coach Darren Lehmann. 

'The leadership group knew about it', Smith (right) admitted following Saturday's action

‘The leadership group knew about it’, Smith (right) admitted following Saturday’s action

‘This was premeditated and calculated at the break and those guys are in charge of Cameron Bancroft behaving the way he did,’ he said on SEN Radio. 

‘It’s a bigger problem than that, he’s been instructed to do this and anyone in cricket knows the captain and coach are in control of what happens in the team.

‘I love Steve Smith but unfortunately he’s made a serious error and I think it’s going to cost him the captaincy of Australia.’

Gilchrist is due to appear on The Project on Sunday night but said on Channel 10 earlier in the day it was ‘black and white’.

Bancroft and Steve Smith admitted that ball tampering had taken place during the action

‘Australian cricket now and the integrity of Australian cricket is the laughing stock of world sport,’ he said.

‘We’re very quick to damn nations that cheat in any way or go beyond the rules. 

‘This clearly is against the laws of the game and we’ve just had our national captain admit they sat down, premeditated, pre-planned a way to cheat.’ 

Former captain Allan Border was among scores of outraged cricket legends.

Discussing the possibility of Smith being sacked, he wrote in his Fox Sports Australia column: ‘If the ICC and the Australian board decides that Steve Smith is free to play in the fourth Test, I would be comfortable with that.

 

‘But equally, if he has to pay a penalty for his leadership in going down this path I’d be just as comfortable.’ 

He added: It’s hard to explain your emotions when it comes to seeing the Australian team doing something like this – you just feel embarrassed and disappointed.’

England fans demonstrated the point made by Gilchrist and have already created a new song – despite their side being bowled out for just 58 on Thursday in their match against New Zealand in Auckland.

The Barmy Army posted the lyrics on Facebook: ‘Steve Smith is an Aussie. He wears a baggy cap. And when he saw some sticky tape. He said I’m having that. He gave it Cameron Bancroft. Who rubbed it on the ball. Those cheating Aussie convicts. They’ll never change at all!’ 

Former Australia captain Michael Clarke was among scores of outraged cricket legends who expressed their shock on Sunday morning.

Former Australia captain Michael Clarke was among scores of outraged cricket legends who expressed their shock on Sunday morning.

In a press conference after play on Saturday, Smith admitted that he and senior players planned the ball-tampering at lunch on day three but said he won’t be stepping down as captain.

Millions of Australians woke up on Sunday to headlines they could scarcely believe as fans quickly bayed for blood, demanding ‘sack the lot of them.’

Cricket Australia CEO James Sutherland was on the verge of tears as he told reporters at a press conference on Sunday morning: ‘This is a sad day for Australian Cricket.’

He has sent the head of integrity and head of team performance out to South Africa to investigate and said he will not decide on sacking any players until he has seen their report. 

'I have no doubt in my mind that every past Australian cricketer will be absolutely shattered with what we found out this morning,' said Clarke

‘I have no doubt in my mind that every past Australian cricketer will be absolutely shattered with what we found out this morning,’ said Clarke

Clarke called the cheating 'blatant' and 'disrespectful' during an interview on Nine News today

Clarke called the cheating ‘blatant’ and ‘disrespectful’ during an interview on Nine News today

Former Australia captain Michael Clarke has said Steve Smith 'will be sitting in his hotel room right now in tears' after the national cricket team was caught cheating against South Africa

Former Australia captain Michael Clarke has said Steve Smith ‘will be sitting in his hotel room right now in tears’ after the national cricket team was caught cheating against South Africa

Another former captain, Michael Clarke called the cheating ‘blatant’ and ‘disrespectful’ during an interview on Nine News on Sunday morning in which he also refused to rule out a return as team captain, saying: ‘If I was asked by the right people, then I would think about my answer.’ 

He said: ‘I am pretty emotional about it all, to be honest. It is going to be quite hard for me to talk about. I think I have no doubt in my mind Steve Smith will be sitting in his hotel room right now in tears. 

‘I have no doubt in my mind that every past Australian cricketer will be absolutely shattered with what we found out this morning.’ 

He savaged Smith for apparently asking 25-year-old Bancroft to cheat, saying: ‘This is his eighth test match. I can’t believe if the leadership group has made a decision to do this, that they have gone and got the young kid who is playing his eighth test match to do that.

‘As a leader, you can’t ask somebody to do something you are not willing to do something you are not willing to do yourself.’   

Former England captain Michael Vaughan led chorus of condemnation and criticism from other ex-players.

‘Steve Smith,his Team & ALL the management will have to accept that whatever happens in their careers they will all be known for trying to CHEAT the game,’ Vaughan tweeted.

The four-Test series between Australia and South Africa has been marred by a handful of ugly controversies, starting with a staircase clash between David Warner and Quinton de Kock.

Millions of Australians woke up on Sunday to headlines they could scarcely believe as fans quickly bayed for blood, demanding 'sack the lot of them.'

Millions of Australians woke up on Sunday to headlines they could scarcely believe as fans quickly bayed for blood, demanding ‘sack the lot of them.’

‘It’s a sad day for Australian cricket’: CEO James Sutherland’s full statement on the cheating scandal 

Cricket Australia CEO James Sutherland was on the verge of tears as he told reporters at a press conference on Sunday morning: ‘This is a sad day for Australian Cricket.’

He has sent the head of integrity and head of team performance out to South Africa to investigate and said he will not decide on sacking any players until he has seen their report. Here is his full statement:

Thanks for joining us. Just wanted to say at the outset that I was extremely disappointed and shocked to hear the news and read the news this morning after the events in Cape Town yesterday.

From a Cricket Australia perspective we regard this as a extremely serious issue and in a moment I will go into steps that will be put in place to understand more about it. Australian cricket fans want to be proud of their cricket team, they want to be proud of the Australian cricket team. 

Cricket Australia CEO James Sutherland was on the verge of tears as he told reporters at a press conference on Sunday morning: ‘This is a sad day for Australian Cricket.’

'I was extremely disappointed and shocked to hear the news and read the news this morning after the events in Cape Town yesterday,' said Sutherland

‘I was extremely disappointed and shocked to hear the news and read the news this morning after the events in Cape Town yesterday,’ said Sutherland

And I think this morning they have every reason to wake up and not be proud of the team. It’s a very sad day for Australian cricket. One of the unique things about the game of cricket is that it’s to be played not only within the laws of the game but in the spirit of the game.

And activities on the field yesterday in Cape Town are neither within the laws of the game or within the laws of the game or within the spirit of the game. And for us at Cricket Australia that’s extremely disappointing, but more importantly for Australian cricket fans it’s extremely disappointing as well. 

Cameron Bancroft was charged under the ICC code of conduct, and accepted that charge and penalty that came with it. And after the game he and Steve Smith spoke about that matter. Unfortunately that’s not the end of it and can’t be the end of it.

We have a responsibility to take this further and to understand more about the issue. And we will over the next couple of days get a deep understanding of what happened and why, and to that end I have asked our head of integrity Ian Roy to travel to South Africa today.

He has sent the head of integrity and head of team performance out to South Africa to investigate and said he will not decide on sacking any players until he has seen their report

Pat Howard, head of team performance will also go with him, and they will also go with him, and they will be on the ground in South Africa tomorrow. Ian’s brief will be to gather the relevant information that we need to address this matter and to understand it better. 

Understand that’s not necessarily the fullness of response that everyone is looking for right now, but you will appreciate that there is an element of process that needs to be undertaken here and you will understand that by appointing our head of integrity to this project it is being dealt with as a matter of urgency and seriousness. 

It will be dealt with promptly, we will work very hard over the next couple of days to get to the bottom of it, to understand the big picture, to understand the detail and to be making further comment on that in due course. 

Again, I just want to repeat two things – one is we are extremely disappointed and shocked at what we woke up to this morning and, secondly, we are dealing with this issue with the up most urgency and seriousness. Thanks

 

 



Read more at DailyMail.co.uk